|
Post by mayugem on Aug 24, 2011 2:00:44 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by songbirdsally on Aug 24, 2011 2:21:47 GMT -5
Liam played a fair game here
|
|
|
Post by Velo on Aug 24, 2011 2:38:29 GMT -5
I still think the whole idea was ridiculous in itself, but I'm glad Liam's came to his senses.
|
|
|
Post by CFC2013 on Aug 24, 2011 2:42:34 GMT -5
I think signs of regret are being displayed by both parties about the Oasis split. Obviously that doesn't mean headlines tomorrow will say Oasis are back together, and I doubt that will ever happen, but regret is always a good sign.
|
|
|
Post by ceskojr on Aug 24, 2011 2:43:45 GMT -5
eh..a planned scenario, nothing else I mean not so much effort is put in this and we all fall for it like we don't know brothers and their management and what are capable of doing. I'm so disappointed with this. I hope they come up next time with something else other than blaming each other
|
|
|
Post by BEng on Aug 24, 2011 3:47:47 GMT -5
This is really weird. "Oh, Noel thought I had a hangover! Better sue him." 2 days later: "Oh okay, Noel still thinks that I had a hangover but confirmed I had a doctors note (something that could easily be proved anyway), everything's fine!"
He never said he was wrong about Liam having a hangover, he only said that if what he had said offended Liam, he's sorry.
Unfortunately I doubt that this was a publicity stunt, but it would've been a very good one!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 24, 2011 4:30:46 GMT -5
Now let's let the music do the talking...
|
|
|
Post by mimmihopps on Aug 24, 2011 6:07:44 GMT -5
It's been 2 years now. It's about time to look forward, not afterward.
The way Oasis had to split up was the big shame. I wish they would have called the day in an another way.
|
|
|
Post by thomaslivesforever on Aug 24, 2011 6:20:49 GMT -5
Fair play Liam, all it was in honesty was a gentle nudge to Noel that Liam won't except him going around saying anything he wants with impunity. They are not in a band together any more. Liam no longer has to put up with it.
Gordon Smart is a vile sychophant.
|
|
|
Post by kelli on Aug 24, 2011 7:57:34 GMT -5
Fair play Liam, all it was in honesty was a gentle nudge to Noel that Liam won't except him going around saying anything he wants with impunity. They are not in a band together any more. Liam no longer has to put up with it. Gordon Smart is a vile sychophant. Less tom, less... you're letting your pseudo-imparcial mask drop a tiiiny bit, eh?
|
|
|
Post by thomaslivesforever on Aug 24, 2011 8:07:41 GMT -5
When did I ever say I was completely impartial? No one here is.
I'm happy to discuss any points in my post you disagree with.
|
|
|
Post by Jessica on Aug 24, 2011 9:15:00 GMT -5
Jazz fusion?
|
|
|
Post by kelli on Aug 24, 2011 9:19:03 GMT -5
When did I ever say I was completely impartial? No one here is. I'm happy to discuss any points in my post you disagree with. No Tom, you are not impartial, but most of the times you try to make believe your opinions come from some kind of a neutral ground, when, in fact you seem more of a liam fan than an oasis fan, but you are entitled to this. Just to let you know my opinion, and keeping as earthly as I can: Noel made a stupid offhand comment regarding the reasons for the cancellation of a gig, but that was just a matter of how uou looked at facts really. Liam really just aggravated a chronic laringytis by being childish and unprofessional the night before. So guess what? He was claiming Noel was questioning his professionalism because he DID have laringytis... THE SHOCK, THE HORROR! If he wanted people not questioning his professionalism then he, as a professional singer should avoid whatever factors increased the probability of developing and aggravating a laringytis. End of story in my opinion. All the rest is just a shitty soup opera. I am glad Noel apologised because at least one of them was mature enough not to let stupidity like this grow further. And for the record, he didn't apologise for the fact that he thought Liam was hungover, he apologised given the fact that it had offended him (the silly offended virgin role, imo). I just find it funny that Liam dropped the charge now and wonder what kind of impact did a foto of him getting pissed that night had in his decision. Also, I don't appeciate the sun or gordon smart in the slightest, but he disd us all a favour publishing that foto... I also wonder is the reason you think his syncopant related in any way to the fact that he dropped a bomb on Liam's claims the day after? By the way, I'm off. I'm really not interested in discussing anything with you as from what I've seen it strikingly resembles talking to a deaf wall
|
|
|
Post by Rolo on Aug 24, 2011 9:25:50 GMT -5
Fairplay Liam.
|
|
|
Post by bwilder on Aug 24, 2011 9:29:39 GMT -5
2014... you heard it here first.
|
|
|
Post by thomaslivesforever on Aug 24, 2011 9:51:27 GMT -5
When did I ever say I was completely impartial? No one here is. I'm happy to discuss any points in my post you disagree with. No Tom, you are not impartial, but most of the times you try to make believe your opinions come from some kind of a neutral ground, when, in fact you seem more of a liam fan than an oasis fan, but you are entitled to this. Just to let you know my opinion, and keeping as earthly as I can: Noel made a stupid offhand comment regarding the reasons for the cancellation of a gig, but that was just a matter of how uou looked at facts really. Liam really just aggravated a chronic laringytis by being childish and unprofessional the night before. So guess what? He was claiming Noel was questioning his professionalism because he DID have laringytis... THE SHOCK, THE HORROR! If he wanted people not questioning his professionalism then he, as a professional singer should avoid whatever factors increased the probability of developing and aggravating a laringytis. End of story in my opinion. All the rest is just a shitty soup opera. I am glad Noel apologised because at least one of them was mature enough not to let stupidity like this grow further. And for the record, he didn't apologise for the fact that he thought Liam was hungover, he apologised given the fact that it had offended him (the silly offended virgin role, imo). I just find it funny that Liam dropped the charge now and wonder what kind of impact did a foto of him getting pissed that night had in his decision. Also, I don't appeciate the sun or gordon smart in the slightest, but he disd us all a favour publishing that foto... I also wonder is the reason you think his syncopant related in any way to the fact that he dropped a bomb on Liam's claims the day after? By the way, I'm off. I'm really not interested in discussing anything with you as from what I've seen it strikingly resembles talking to a deaf wall You comment on Liam's maturity and yet didn't he say in his statement that he had sought an amicable resolution and failed? So who then allowed this stupidity to get out of hand bearing in mind that Noel did give an apology (of sorts). That photo was not a 'bomb' as you so call it. A picture of a man having a beer is hardly evidence of him getting smashed. Although if you had read the written piece that went with it you might think that Liam had drank 3 bottles of whiskey, done a mountain of cocaine and swallowed a hundred pills. Thats what Gorden does for his buddy Noel, and simply for being part of that filthy newspaper he should be exiled. If you do not wish to debate with me, then do not quote me. Its pretty simple.
|
|
|
Post by kelli on Aug 24, 2011 10:16:34 GMT -5
No Tom, you are not impartial, but most of the times you try to make believe your opinions come from some kind of a neutral ground, when, in fact you seem more of a liam fan than an oasis fan, but you are entitled to this. Just to let you know my opinion, and keeping as earthly as I can: Noel made a stupid offhand comment regarding the reasons for the cancellation of a gig, but that was just a matter of how uou looked at facts really. Liam really just aggravated a chronic laringytis by being childish and unprofessional the night before. So guess what? He was claiming Noel was questioning his professionalism because he DID have laringytis... THE SHOCK, THE HORROR! If he wanted people not questioning his professionalism then he, as a professional singer should avoid whatever factors increased the probability of developing and aggravating a laringytis. End of story in my opinion. All the rest is just a shitty soup opera. I am glad Noel apologised because at least one of them was mature enough not to let stupidity like this grow further. And for the record, he didn't apologise for the fact that he thought Liam was hungover, he apologised given the fact that it had offended him (the silly offended virgin role, imo). I just find it funny that Liam dropped the charge now and wonder what kind of impact did a foto of him getting pissed that night had in his decision. Also, I don't appeciate the sun or gordon smart in the slightest, but he disd us all a favour publishing that foto... I also wonder is the reason you think his syncopant related in any way to the fact that he dropped a bomb on Liam's claims the day after? By the way, I'm off. I'm really not interested in discussing anything with you as from what I've seen it strikingly resembles talking to a deaf wall You comment on Liam's maturity and yet didn't he say in his statement that he had sought an amicable resolution and failed? So who then allowed this stupidity to get out of hand bearing in mind that Noel did give an apology (of sorts). That photo was not a 'bomb' as you so call it. A picture of a man having a beer is hardly evidence of him getting smashed. Although if you had read the written piece that went with it you might think that Liam had drank 3 bottles of whiskey, done a mountain of cocaine and swallowed a hundred pills. Thats what Gorden does for his buddy Noel, and simply for being part of that filthy newspaper he should be exiled. If you do not wish to debate with me, then do not quote me. Its pretty simple. Well, nothing new about your posts then. I've followed oasis for nearly 20 years now, and I've seen plenty if Liam's immaturity, and plenty of his amicablitity, he tries to have an apology based on a half truth, really? Maybe noel didn't expect him to go ahead with it, or he didn't feel he had something to apologise for, which in my opinion, he didn't.This is So petty, so filthy it's almost unbelievable... As far as that night goes, it's not ony that photo, it's the fact that he heckled trough the whole wolves vs city game, the fact that ppl tweeted about him being drunk after the gig etc. Sometimes you have to add 2 and 2 you know. Regardless of the sun's photo, everyone knew what had happened, that was just a physical elemet added to it, regardless Gordon being buddies with Noel. I only called it a bomb because it effectively put out many of you crying in his defence. Besides this this is an open forum, and if Liam decided to make his acts so public and sued someone than he better be sure he was 100% right, which he hadn't. So yes, that was a bloody immature, precipitated action that translates his personality well. It's the last time I've quoted you if it annoys you so much and I'm really unwilling to talk to someone so locked inside your fagile arguments. I let you take the bike.
|
|
|
Post by thomaslivesforever on Aug 24, 2011 10:29:39 GMT -5
You comment on Liam's maturity and yet didn't he say in his statement that he had sought an amicable resolution and failed? So who then allowed this stupidity to get out of hand bearing in mind that Noel did give an apology (of sorts). That photo was not a 'bomb' as you so call it. A picture of a man having a beer is hardly evidence of him getting smashed. Although if you had read the written piece that went with it you might think that Liam had drank 3 bottles of whiskey, done a mountain of cocaine and swallowed a hundred pills. Thats what Gorden does for his buddy Noel, and simply for being part of that filthy newspaper he should be exiled. If you do not wish to debate with me, then do not quote me. Its pretty simple. Well, nothing new about your posts then. I've followed oasis for nearly 20 years now, and I've seen plenty if Liam's immaturity, and plenty of his amicablitity. As far as that night goes, it's not ony that photo, it's the fact that he heckled trough the whole wolves vs city game, the fact that ppl tweeted about him being drunk after the gig etc. Sometimes you have to add 2 and 2 you know. Regardless of the sun's photo, everyone knew what had happened, that was just a physical elemet added to it, regardless Gordon being buddies with Noel. I only called it a bomb because it effectively put out many of you crying in his defence. Besides this this is an open forum, and if Liam decided to make his acts so public and sued someone than he better be sure he had 100% reason, which he hadn't. So yes, that was a bloody immature, precipitated action that translates his personality well. It's the last time I've quoted you if it annoys you so much and I'm really unwilling to talk to someone so locked inside your fagile arguments. I let you take the bike. It didn't put that much of an end to it did it? Noel still gave an apology. Which would suggest that Liam at least had a bit of point. So that photo really proved nothing except a bloke was having a beer. I haven't seen these tweets or a proper article to the wolves thing, so if you could link me that would be grand. I also know someone who was backstage at V and spent quite a time with Liam who said he did have a few beers after the gig but was in good form. You don't annoy me at all and you are the one throwing insults about. You said you weren't interested in disscussing anything but you were the one quoting me. I just pointed out that if you don't want discussion dont quote me. Again, its not a hard concept.
|
|
|
Post by gdforever on Aug 24, 2011 10:51:41 GMT -5
This is really the best resolution possible.
Good on Noel for taking the higher road and acknowledging that Liam did have a note and had been diagnosed and apologized for having offended him despite the fact that he made it quite blatant that he still has the exact same opinion. It's actually more than I would have expected of him. He was right that it was getting silly and uncool.
I think the photos probably did have a little to do with Liam deciding that he would accept. But good on him for accepting anyways.
It was a compromise on both sides. And thank god that Noel has already decided not to talk any more about the split.
|
|
|
Post by Beady’s Here Now on Aug 24, 2011 11:07:46 GMT -5
Thank serious fuck for that.
|
|
|
Post by Nyron Nosworthy on Aug 24, 2011 12:52:35 GMT -5
Fair play Liam, all it was in honesty was a gentle nudge to Noel that Liam won't except him going around saying anything he wants with impunity. They are not in a band together any more. Liam no longer has to put up with it. Gordon Smart is a vile sychophant. Totally agree. It was never going to go to court, and like I've just said on the other thread, you can guarantee they'll both be very careful about what they say about each other in future.
|
|
|
Post by thuperthonic on Aug 24, 2011 12:59:18 GMT -5
Who are these sources that know what Peggy said to Liam lol
|
|
|
Post by songbirdsally on Aug 24, 2011 13:11:11 GMT -5
Who are these sources that know what Peggy said to Liam lol Noel
|
|
dion
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 362
|
Post by dion on Aug 24, 2011 13:19:55 GMT -5
When are these pictures supposed to have surfaced? There was photos of him on the net about 3-4 days after V... it's not like Liam was hiding the fact he was drinking.
|
|
|
Post by gdforever on Aug 24, 2011 13:23:58 GMT -5
They surface a couple days after the lawsuit was filed.
I don't know what pictures came out 2 years ago.
Who cares. The only think that Noel was airing was that they had to cancel a gig in his opinion because of Liam's drinking. You can be rest assured Noel is as pissed about that as he always was. He was stupid to use the hangover to get that across though.
|
|