|
Post by yeayeayeah on Jun 22, 2013 23:42:16 GMT -5
Chris wasn't really an Oasis drummer though. Stones Roses debut is brilliant but Oasis are better overall. it doesn't really matter though, its all just preference. Technically no, but I really love his drumming. IMO he's one of the best drummers around today. His drumming is one of the few reasons I actually listen to Different Gear, Still Speeding nowadays. He really adds a lot to the music for me at least. Yea, he is an amazing drummer, I wish he had played on an Oasis album
|
|
|
Post by Bruno on Jun 23, 2013 0:01:17 GMT -5
Technically no, but I really love his drumming. IMO he's one of the best drummers around today. His drumming is one of the few reasons I actually listen to Different Gear, Still Speeding nowadays. He really adds a lot to the music for me at least. Yea, he is an amazing drummer, I wish he had played on an Oasis album Me too.
|
|
|
Post by stoneroses on Jun 23, 2013 12:35:28 GMT -5
Chris Sharrock is the drummer of our generation, thank you very much. Hmmmmmm don't think so, Chris is also a great drummer but Reni is the master, no doubt about that what so ever!!!
|
|
|
Post by Drums91 on Jun 24, 2013 12:34:41 GMT -5
Chris Sharrock is the drummer of our generation, thank you very much. Hmmmmmm don't think so, Chris is also a great drummer but Reni is the master, no doubt about that what so ever!!! Chris has got better with age wheras Reni has declined majorly from what he once was, that's coming from a huge fan of Reni
|
|
zgb
Oasis Roadie
"I'll paint you the picture..."
Posts: 224
|
Post by zgb on Jun 24, 2013 20:31:20 GMT -5
it's like saying sex pistols are better than the clash. they made one fucking album! (which is a great album, but...)
|
|
|
Post by AlissonBrazil on Jun 24, 2013 22:54:49 GMT -5
Reni is really really great. But Chris is a fucking monster!!!
|
|
|
Post by stoneroses on Jun 25, 2013 5:35:12 GMT -5
it's like saying sex pistols are better than the clash. they made one fucking album! (which is a great album, but...) Quality over Quantity my dear friend wins every time... Stone Roses Vs Definately Maybe I Wanna be Adored > Rock 'n' Roll Star She Bangs the Drums > Shakermaker Waterfall > Live Forever Don't Stop > Up in the Sky Bye Bye Badman > Columbia Elizabeth My Dear < Supersonic Sugar Spun Sister > Bring It on Down Made Of Stone > Cigarettes & Alcohol Shoot You Down > Digsy's Dinner This is The One > Slide AwayI am The Resurrection > Married with Children One loss for the Roses and that is Supersonic being better than Elizabeth my dear. The rest is a win for the Roses.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 25, 2013 5:37:56 GMT -5
it's like saying sex pistols are better than the clash. they made one fucking album! (which is a great album, but...) Quality over Quantity my dear friend wins every time... Stone Roses Vs Definately Maybe I Wanna be Adored > Rock 'n' Roll Star She Bangs the Drums > Shakermaker Waterfall > Live Forever Don't Stop > Up in the Sky Bye Bye Badman > Columbia Elizabeth My Dear < Supersonic Sugar Spun Sister > Bring It on Down Made Of Stone > Cigarettes & Alcohol Shoot You Down > Digsy's Dinner This is The One > Slide AwayI am The Resurrection > Married with Children One loss for the Roses and that is Supersonic being better than Elizabeth my dear. The rest is a win for the Roses. A song that consists of one statement repeated over and over again.... I don't have to sell my soul He's already in me I don't need to sell my soul He's already in me I wanna be adored I wanna be adored I don't have to sell my soul He's already in me I don't need to sell my soul He's already in me I wanna be adored I wanna be adored Adored I wanna be adored You adore me You adore me You adore me I wanna I wanna I wanna be adored Wanna I wanna I wanna be adored I wanna I wanna I wanna be adored I wanna I wanna I gotta be adored I wanna be adored Better than Rock 'n' Roll Star? Behave. Now do What's the Story against Second Coming... We'll see how that turns up
|
|
|
Post by ruchin on Jun 25, 2013 5:41:35 GMT -5
it's like saying sex pistols are better than the clash. they made one fucking album! (which is a great album, but...) Quality over Quantity my dear friend wins every time... Stone Roses Vs Definately Maybe I Wanna be Adored > Rock 'n' Roll Star She Bangs the Drums > Shakermaker Waterfall > Live Forever Don't Stop > Up in the Sky Bye Bye Badman > Columbia Elizabeth My Dear < Supersonic Sugar Spun Sister > Bring It on Down Made Of Stone > Cigarettes & Alcohol Shoot You Down > Digsy's Dinner This is The One > Slide AwayI am The Resurrection > Married with Children One loss for the Roses and that is Supersonic being better than Elizabeth my dear. The rest is a win for the Roses. I actually think your right that The Stone Roses is better than Definatley Maybe but coming on an Oasis fanbase forum and protesting the point is stupid.
|
|
|
Post by stoneroses on Jun 25, 2013 6:28:55 GMT -5
Quality over Quantity my dear friend wins every time... Stone Roses Vs Definately Maybe I Wanna be Adored > Rock 'n' Roll Star She Bangs the Drums > Shakermaker Waterfall > Live Forever Don't Stop > Up in the Sky Bye Bye Badman > Columbia Elizabeth My Dear < Supersonic Sugar Spun Sister > Bring It on Down Made Of Stone > Cigarettes & Alcohol Shoot You Down > Digsy's Dinner This is The One > Slide AwayI am The Resurrection > Married with Children One loss for the Roses and that is Supersonic being better than Elizabeth my dear. The rest is a win for the Roses. I actually think your right that The Stone Roses is better than Definatley Maybe but coming on an Oasis fanbase forum and protesting the point is stupid. Yeah, definitely maybe protesting the point is stupid, but I'm having fun doing so!!! I was originally drawn to this forum when reading about Reni holding up the "Who the Fuck is Liam Gallagher t-shirt" and when reading some of the comments on here I felt the need to make a few comments of my own. The Thing is I Really love Oasis too!!!! and there's nothing wrong with a bit of friendly banter.
|
|
|
Post by WirralRiddler on Jun 25, 2013 7:10:06 GMT -5
it's like saying sex pistols are better than the clash. they made one fucking album! (which is a great album, but...) Well IMO the Pistols were/are better than the clash, can't explain my reasons really, i like the clash a lot but i just put the Pistols on a different level, where as for me its the opposite with the Roses and Oasis. I like the roses a lot but again i put Oasis and a different level completely. In fact these opinions actually contradict each other but i dont give a shit. The Pistols are better despite having only the one proper album, but Oasis are better than the roses because of the quantity of great songs they have to there name. And for that reason i would even put Oasis above the Pistols themselves, even though i absolutely love the pistols. I personally get bored if i listen to too much Roses, i like a fair few of their songs, but i never find myself wanting to listen to them much.
|
|
|
Post by WirralRiddler on Jun 25, 2013 7:12:42 GMT -5
it's like saying sex pistols are better than the clash. they made one fucking album! (which is a great album, but...) Quality over Quantity my dear friend wins every time... Stone Roses Vs Definately Maybe I Wanna be Adored > Rock 'n' Roll Star She Bangs the Drums > Shakermaker Waterfall > Live Forever Don't Stop > Up in the Sky Bye Bye Badman > Columbia Elizabeth My Dear < Supersonic Sugar Spun Sister > Bring It on Down Made Of Stone > Cigarettes & Alcohol Shoot You Down > Digsy's Dinner This is The One > Slide AwayI am The Resurrection > Married with Children One loss for the Roses and that is Supersonic being better than Elizabeth my dear. The rest is a win for the Roses. I only agree with 3 of those ratings, i'll give you the obvious Supersonic one, She Bangs the Drum over Shakermaker and maybe I am the resuurection over married with children, but as for the rest, NO WAY PEDRO.
|
|
|
Post by forestfan on Jun 25, 2013 7:30:12 GMT -5
wtf anyone who denies Reni is the best is deluded
RENI is simply beyond words
12/10
|
|
|
Post by nahuel89p on Jun 25, 2013 8:00:53 GMT -5
it's like saying sex pistols are better than the clash. they made one fucking album! (which is a great album, but...) Quality over Quantity my dear friend wins every time... Stone Roses Vs Definately Maybe I Wanna be Adored > Rock 'n' Roll Star She Bangs the Drums > Shakermaker Waterfall > Live Forever Don't Stop > Up in the Sky Bye Bye Badman > Columbia Elizabeth My Dear < Supersonic Sugar Spun Sister > Bring It on Down Made Of Stone > Cigarettes & Alcohol Shoot You Down > Digsy's Dinner This is The One > Slide AwayI am The Resurrection > Married with Children One loss for the Roses and that is Supersonic being better than Elizabeth my dear. The rest is a win for the Roses. Putting aside the fact that I don't agree in some comparisons, I gotta say TSR is pure class, no doubts. But since it's songs are more clean than the ones in DM, they may look better than they actually are, more refined, better production, more layers, more arrangements. We all know what's with DM production. Raw and compressed. But TSR has some cheesy, sickeningly sweet moments on the other hand. It also has one of the brightests moments in music (I am the resurrection outro). DM has less class, surely, but it puts you on the track. I love TSR, but I've always gave way more listens to Definitely Maybe, and even to Second Coming (yes) as well. It's perhaps my weakness for straightforward rock n roll. Stone roses never came as near as Oasis when it comes to live performance anyway. Nothing beats the 95'-96' gigs.
|
|
|
Post by Gin & Tonic on Jun 25, 2013 8:05:59 GMT -5
I love the Stone Roses but some of the things said in this thread are ridiculous, This Is The One > Slide Away? Ian Brown vocals = Liam vocals? Second Coming > Definitely Maybe? Come on now...
|
|
|
Post by madeofstone on Jun 25, 2013 10:34:30 GMT -5
I love the Stone Roses but some of the things said in this thread are ridiculous, This Is The One > Slide Away? Ian Brown vocals = Liam vocals? Second Coming > Definitely Maybe? Come on now... There's nothing wrong with the Second Coming, Second Coming is an awesome album. Many people including myself would rate this album as being better than Definitely Maybe!!! Thing with the Roses is there versatility, Second Coming was only regarded as a flop at the time because it was very different to there first album. That's the thing I like about the Roses there ability to change style and still sound fucking amazing. To me Oasis never really had this quality, they got lucky and come out with the right songs at the right time, its something they will never be able to repeat again!! In all honesty people got board with Oasis in the end because they couldn't change there style, they always sounded the same!! "It takes time for people to fall in love with you....but its inevitable"
|
|
|
Post by cloudburster on Jun 25, 2013 11:04:54 GMT -5
This is The One > Slide Away = pure retardation
|
|
|
Post by cloudburster on Jun 25, 2013 11:09:37 GMT -5
I love the Stone Roses but some of the things said in this thread are ridiculous, This Is The One > Slide Away? Ian Brown vocals = Liam vocals? Second Coming > Definitely Maybe? Come on now... There's nothing wrong with the Second Coming, Second Coming is an awesome album. Many people including myself would rate this album as being better than Definitely Maybe!!! Thing with the Roses is there versatility, Second Coming was only regarded as a flop at the time because it was very different to there first album. That's the thing I like about the Roses there ability to change style and still sound fucking amazing To me Oasis never really had this quality, they got lucky and come out with the right songs at the right time, its something they will never be able to repeat again!! In all honesty people got board with Oasis in the end because they couldn't change there style, they always sounded the same!! "It takes time for people to fall in love with you....but its inevitable" Just a couple of things I have flagged up 1. By 'many people' do you mean Stone Roses fans, ie the minority? 2. It is still regarded as a flop (not just 'at the time') because it is a much worse album than the first, nothing to do with its style 3. Is that why they were playing Heaton Park, Wembley and Slane Castle in 2009, 15 years after their first album? All silly points. Stop being so silly.
|
|
|
Post by Drums91 on Jun 25, 2013 11:36:34 GMT -5
wtf anyone who denies Reni is the best is deluded RENI is simply beyond words 12/10 On record and in the gigs in te 90's he is out of this world but after seeing them 3 times since they got back together I've been underwhelmed each time by his drumming, Matt Helders on the other hand blew me away
|
|
|
Post by forestfan on Jun 25, 2013 11:38:15 GMT -5
This is The One > Slide Away = pure retardation Just take your Oasis/NGFB/BE hat off for a second and realise that TITO is an amazing 'anthemic' song and Slide Away is a great tune too can we stop the SR VS OASIS debate The Stone Roses are 10/10 Oasis, for the most part are 10/10 stop being offended by a 'joke' from Reni and realise that without the roses, there is no live4ever, because there there would of been NO oasis I hope people listen to me and read this
|
|