|
Post by glider on Aug 30, 2015 21:37:31 GMT -5
1. Don't Look Back in Anger 2. Champagne Supernova 3. Some Might Say 4. Morning Glory 5. Cast No Shadow 6. Hello 7. Wonderwall 8. Hey Now! 9. She's Electric 10. Roll with It 1. Some Might Say 2. Don't Look Back in Anger 3. Champagne Supernova 4. Morning Glory 5. Cast No Shadow 6. Hey Now! 7. Hello 8. Wonderwall 9. She's Electric 10. Roll With It
|
|
|
Post by beentherenow on Aug 31, 2015 5:35:04 GMT -5
1.Champagne Supernova 2.Some Might Say 3.Wonderwall 4.Morning Glory 5.Cast No Shadow 6.Dont Look Back in Anger 7.Hello 8.Roll With It 9.Hey Now 10.Shes Electric
|
|
|
Post by cammightsay on Oct 14, 2015 15:52:59 GMT -5
Some Might Say Cast No Shadow Wonderwall DLBIA Hello Morning Glory She's electric Champagne Supernova Hey now Roll with it Swamp song
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 14, 2015 15:59:56 GMT -5
1. Champagne Supernova (10/10) 2. Don't Look Back in Anger (10/10) 3. Wonderwall (8/10) 4. Some Might Say (8/10) 5. Morning Glory (8/10) 6. Cast No Shadow (7.5/10) 7. Hello (6/10) 8. She's Electric (6/10) 9. Roll With It (6/10) 10. Hey Now! (6/10) 11. Excerpts (5/10) *sigh*...it started so well... I was reading through this, came across mine and thought "This guy knows it" before realising it was mine... My ranking is still the same and it's still on the money.
|
|
|
Post by The Crimson Rambler on Oct 14, 2015 16:56:08 GMT -5
1. Champagne Supernova (10/10) 2. Don't Look Back in Anger (10/10) 3. Wonderwall (8/10) 4. Some Might Say (8/10) 5. Morning Glory (8/10) 6. Cast No Shadow (7.5/10) 7. Hello (6/10) 8. She's Electric (6/10) 9. Roll With It (6/10) 10. Hey Now! (6/10) 11. Excerpts (5/10) *sigh*...it started so well... I was reading through this, came across mine and thought "This guy knows it" before realising it was mine... My ranking is still the same and it's still on the money. 8/10 for Some Might Say? What's the guy gotta do... 6/10 for Roll With It? Someone needs to appreciate a good hook...
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 14, 2015 17:35:08 GMT -5
I was reading through this, came across mine and thought "This guy knows it" before realising it was mine... My ranking is still the same and it's still on the money. 8/10 for Some Might Say? What's the guy gotta do... 6/10 for Roll With It? Someone needs to appreciate a good hook... Roll With It's hook is great, but the production and overall melody is just...ugh. Could very happily live without it. Some Might Say is a solid 8, not a stone cold classic like Champagne Supernova or Don't Look Back in Anger but a great rock song with more melodies than you can shake a tambourine at.
|
|
|
Post by Longtime Servant of the Gun on Oct 14, 2015 18:11:05 GMT -5
Haven't seen this thread before...Here goes
Don't look back in anger 10/10 Champagne supernova 10/10 Some might say 9/10 Hello 9/10 Wonderwall 9/10 Cast no shadow 8/10 Hey now 8/10 Morning glory 8/10 Swamp song #1 Swamp song #2 Roll with it 6/10 She's electric 6/10
|
|
|
Post by The Crimson Rambler on Oct 14, 2015 18:30:30 GMT -5
8/10 for Some Might Say? What's the guy gotta do... 6/10 for Roll With It? Someone needs to appreciate a good hook... Roll With It's hook is great, but the production and overall melody is just...ugh. Could very happily live without it. Some Might Say is a solid 8, not a stone cold classic like Champagne Supernova or Don't Look Back in Anger but a great rock song with more melodies than you can shake a tambourine at. I appreciate that fact Roll With It is a divisive track and one of the less impressive songs from the album, but taken out of it's 'classic' context a 6/10 seems at least a little harsh for one of the band's most memorable numbers. I personally think it punches out some of the catchiest hooks Noel has ever written... so much so, I think people actually find it rather annoying! I agree that the production doesn't make the most of the material, but I think it's very much an underloved track. It's not often rock songs come along quite that catchy. I can let an objectionable song slide but not only is Some Might Say a stone cold classic, but it might just be Noel's best ever song and one of the easiest 10s I'd ever, EVER give.
|
|
|
Post by Aman on Oct 15, 2015 3:46:41 GMT -5
I love the last minute of Roll With It.
It's just great.
Tingly stuff.
|
|
|
Post by Aman on Oct 15, 2015 3:50:19 GMT -5
Cast No Shadow could have been the best Oasis song in my opinion if the album version sounded more like the live version. Live at Maine Road or Knebworth is just ... It's repetitiveness lets it down really. To the point the song becomes a bit annoying to listen to. Honestly, I'd have Hey Now above Cast No Shadow. The song's just got more substance to it.
|
|
|
Post by andybellwillring on Oct 15, 2015 5:29:05 GMT -5
1. Don't Look Back in Anger (10/10) 2. Hello (9/10) 3. Morning Glory (9/10) 4. Champagne Supernova (9/10) 5. She's Electric (9/10) 6. Some Might Say (8/10) 7. Wonderwall (8/10) 8. Roll With It (7/10) 9. Cast No Shadow (7/10) 10. Hey Now! (5/10)
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 15, 2015 6:28:18 GMT -5
Cast No Shadow is a brilliant song. Sure a second verse wouldn't have been too much but melodically, lyrically, it is Noel on his throne.
Roll With It is not a bad song at all, it's just not at the same level of some Noel's songs at that time: Wonderwall, The Masterplan, Some Might Say, Champagne Supernova, Don't Look Back In Anger, Acquiesce, etc. Difficult to reach that "standard" for every song, innit ? That said, Roll With It has good melody, combined to a feeling of euphoria when you're in the mood.
Hey Now! is the first "dark" Oasis song. It has a particular atmosphere who detonates with some songs on the album (DLBIA, Some Might Say for example, Hey Now! being between these two in the tracklisting). It's maybe too long but it's never close to a "shit song". It's just a different side about Noel's songwriting.
My ranking for today:
1. Champagne Supernova 2. Don't Look Back In Anger 3. Wonderwall 4. Some Might Say 5. Morning Glory 6. Cast No Shadow 7. Hello 8. She's Electric 9. Roll With It 10.Hey Now!
|
|