|
Post by Frank Lee Vulgar on Nov 2, 2016 17:42:17 GMT -5
]I couldn't disagree more. The HFB songs you mention are some of the very few I can't imagine Oasis having recorded and to be honest had Noel kept them for himself to sing he could have put them on there where he wanted. If there was no group objection to GOYHHL being put on a record I could hardly see one being given to those. I think BE is at least as different as anything Noel has done if not more so. Not that there's a problem with that but I find it a strange stick to beat Liam with given what Noel has released since 2009. I might not have made my point clear enough. Of course many HFB songs could still work under the Oasis name, most of the first album for sure, much fewer songs from CY. But not only are they different enough from Oasis to not directly invite the comparison (which might be down to the lack of Liam singing, but still), they are also simply better songs. Both HFB albums are simply written better than anything since Be Here Now, and good songs always stand on their own. Compare that to Beady Eye. First album, closer to Oasis than the first HFB album; the songs much worse than those on HFB or any 2000s Oasis album really. BE, better songs but still only a couple exceptional tracks, and while the direction was good, it was dragged down by having as many dull and uninspired as new and exciting songs. Basically, Noel could afford to change nothing from Oasis because he still has the songs. Even he decided to change things up a little for CY, but if everything else fails, he writes songs that are good enough for any of his albums to be successfull. That is simply not the case for Liam - the songwriting in Beady Eye was miles below Noel's, and Liam will obviously never be as good as Noel in that category. Liam still has his voice, but you can't expect him to fire up fast rock songs like he's 24. He needs to do something to distinguish himself, or he'll end up as the Oasis guy who kept being a pale imitation of his former glory when the band split.
|
|
|
Post by Let It 🩸 on Nov 3, 2016 0:47:22 GMT -5
Yet Noel is managing just fine? What does it 'doing pretty good' mean? Doing pretty good means getting through life without catching any std's or ending up in prison on a 10-20 stretch, or at least not catching any std's that can't be cured with a little penicillin and calomine lotion. Frodis knows what I'm talking about. God bless.
|
|
|
Post by Flatulence Panic on Nov 3, 2016 15:47:45 GMT -5
Yeah Bwoi.
|
|
|
Post by Flatulence Panic on Nov 3, 2016 15:53:04 GMT -5
You know there's a completely and INCREDIBLE thread called "What song are you listening", yea? Oh, sorry mum. The forum police are here. I'll post where I want, luv. Cheers.
|
|
|
Post by mimmihopps on Nov 3, 2016 15:58:02 GMT -5
You know there's a completely and INCREDIBLE thread called "What song are you listening", yea? SO GET YOUR GODDAMN POSTS CORRECTLY, GODDAMMIT No need to act like that. Cheers.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 3, 2016 15:59:26 GMT -5
You know there's a completely and INCREDIBLE thread called "What song are you listening", yea? SO GET YOUR GODDAMN POSTS CORRECTLY, GODDAMMIT No need to act like that. Cheers. You know, I'm not even mad. It's just that everywhere I go this guy's posting a song edit: great, now I'm feeling bad. edit2: I won't feel better until I do this so yea, sorry. Even if I didn't mean to sound as it looked like.
|
|