|
Post by Beady’s Here Now on Oct 26, 2012 21:13:56 GMT -5
I think the purists would say "No, only Oasis songs." And I do tend to be a purist and traditionalist by nature.
But songs like IIHAG, RM (reworked and re-released with Liam vocals), EOTR, etc are too strong to ignore.
BDI songs? Meh, I'm not as bothered as much but Wigwam could earn a spot on there.
Imagine developing an Oasis setlist with the Oasis classics, those strong songs from NGHFB and BDI, and possibly a new Oasis record. That would be one hell of a list (as we knew in 2008, even).
And people say Oasis aren't a great band?
So would you include any NGHFB and/or BDI songs in Oasis' reformation set list? (Seriously, IIHAG is the best thing Noel has written in eons).
|
|
|
Post by forestfan on Oct 26, 2012 22:25:42 GMT -5
No. because as to date Stone roses did not play Ian Browns solo tunes like My star and F.E.A.R so no
|
|
|
Post by Lennon2217 on Oct 27, 2012 0:44:43 GMT -5
I think the purists would say "No, only Oasis songs." And I do tend to be a purist and traditionalist by nature. But songs like IIHAG, RM (reworked and re-released with Liam vocals), EOTR, etc are too strong to ignore. BDI songs? Meh, I'm not as bothered as much but Wigwam could earn a spot on there. Imagine developing an Oasis setlist with the Oasis classics, those strong songs from NGHFB and BDI, and possibly a new Oasis record. That would be one hell of a list (as we knew in 2008, even). And people say Oasis aren't a great band? So would you include any NGHFB and/or BDI songs in Oasis' reformation set list? (Seriously, IIHAG is the best thing Noel has written in eons). Liam had his chance with Record Machine, not once but twice. Blew it both times I'm afraid...or at least according to Noel. I still don't understand why it is so tough for Noel to get Liam to lay down vocals for this track. Between the sessions for Death In Vegas, DBTT and DOYS surely Liam had to have given this a shot right?
|
|
|
Post by Jim on Oct 27, 2012 6:16:37 GMT -5
I think the purists would say "No, only Oasis songs." And I do tend to be a purist and traditionalist by nature. But songs like IIHAG, RM (reworked and re-released with Liam vocals), EOTR, etc are too strong to ignore. BDI songs? Meh, I'm not as bothered as much but Wigwam could earn a spot on there. Imagine developing an Oasis setlist with the Oasis classics, those strong songs from NGHFB and BDI, and possibly a new Oasis record. That would be one hell of a list (as we knew in 2008, even). And people say Oasis aren't a great band? So would you include any NGHFB and/or BDI songs in Oasis' reformation set list? (Seriously, IIHAG is the best thing Noel has written in eons). Liam had his chance with Record Machine, not once but twice. Blew it both times I'm afraid...or at least according to Noel. I still don't understand why it is so tough for Noel to get Liam to lay down vocals for this track. Between the sessions for Death In Vegas, DBTT and DOYS surely Liam had to have given this a shot right? For all we know Liam did put a vocal down for Record Machine, there is no evidence to say he hasn't, only a throw away comment by Noel that he went and got married but they could have put the vocals down on the first day of recording rather than Love Like a Bomb or The Nature of Reality for example depending on the session. I'll give two examples why I think Liam did put down a vocal though for the song. Noel has said there are versions of Stop the Clocks with Liam singing and there is also the leaked version of Lord Don't Slow Me Down with Liam on vocals. So it makes sense to me he would have done a rough version at least. Sometimes a song may just not work out, maybe Liam didn't like the direction of the song. And to N4LE's original question, no solo stuff for me.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 27, 2012 6:26:14 GMT -5
I could see Noel wanting to play some of his HFB stuff but for me the songs aren't good enough to get into an oasis setlist, my favourite songs of his are broken arrow and the death of you and me and neither of them sound that good live personally, certainly not compared to the oasis classics like Morning Glory and Supersonic etc... And yes, not a chance any BDI stuff would be played
|
|
|
Post by LlAM on Oct 27, 2012 6:30:16 GMT -5
They should do what Take That and Rodney Williams did;
A Beady Eye set A NGHFB set with Chris, Gem and Andy as the HFB And an Oasis set
|
|
|
Post by Frank Lee Vulgar on Oct 27, 2012 7:40:53 GMT -5
No. because as to date Stone roses did not play Ian Browns solo tunes like My star and F.E.A.R so no That's different. Brown's songs don't fit the style of a Roses gig at all and they are also a lot worse than everything they are playing live. EOTR, IIHAG or Broken Arrow are at least as good as the lead singles from every post-2000 Oasis album, so they definitely do deserve a spot on a possible reunion setlist. If Noel does an acoustic set, why should the band care if he does IIHAG instead of Half the World Away? The fans would definitely love it. Then again Oasis have so much good material that they don't necessarily need the HFB songs. If you take a look at the songs that weren't played live at some point from 2000-2009 for example...stuff like Slide Away, Listen Up, Bring it On Down, Headshrinker, Cast No Shadow, Hello, Roll With It, Some Might Say, All Around The World, D'You Know What I Mean?, The Masterplan, Acquiesce, Gas Panic!(at least I believe all of them were dropped for at least a few gigs) - all of those could be played instead and they would be just as good; even if some of the songs are slightly inferior they are actual classic Oasis songs. Nobody would complain about that.
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Oct 27, 2012 9:11:27 GMT -5
The Masterplan, Acquiesce, Some Might Say, Slide Away, Listen Up and Cast No Shadow are inferior to the HFB's songs you listed?
I want whatever you're on mate!
|
|
|
Post by Frank Lee Vulgar on Oct 27, 2012 10:33:19 GMT -5
The Masterplan, Acquiesce, Some Might Say, Slide Away, Listen Up and Cast No Shadow are inferior to the HFB's songs you listed? I want whatever you're on mate! Sorry, I obviously meant "some of the Oasis songs" (...might be abit worse than the HFB stuff). Most are just as good or better, that was my point ;D
|
|
|
Post by Nyron Nosworthy on Oct 27, 2012 15:14:34 GMT -5
The only one that comes close to the top 25 or so Oasis songs is Everybody's On The Run, and I don't think he does that one justice live. Why would they play the solo songs? They're from a period where they hated each other, presuming they're on good terms if/when this hypothetical gig takes place, why play them?
|
|
|
Post by novascotialad on Oct 27, 2012 16:10:39 GMT -5
you people actually think there's a snowballs chance in hell of this happening? lmfao
|
|
|
Post by jordan71421 on Oct 27, 2012 16:45:27 GMT -5
you people actually think there's a snowballs chance in hell of this happening? lmfao haha exactly, i don't think they'll even reform again
|
|
|
Post by mistakenidentity on Oct 28, 2012 13:02:12 GMT -5
They should do what Take That and Rodney Williams did; A Beady Eye set A NGHFB set with Chris, Gem and Andy as the HFB And an Oasis set I don't see this happening. The Take That/Robbie situation was different because Robbie had a huge solo career and his songs are better than Take That songs. Also, Noel and Liam are probably too lazy to play two sets
|
|
|
Post by mimmihopps on Oct 28, 2012 13:12:24 GMT -5
No way.
|
|
|
Post by ramattack22 on Oct 28, 2012 14:07:44 GMT -5
I'm not opposed to it but I don't think it'll happen. There are too many really good oasis songs. I can't see If I Had A Gun in the setlist over something like The Masterplan. It's fine in a HFB set but not in oasis.
|
|
|
Post by Nyron Nosworthy on Oct 29, 2012 19:04:58 GMT -5
They should do what Take That and Rodney Williams did; A Beady Eye set A NGHFB set with Chris, Gem and Andy as the HFB And an Oasis set I don't see this happening. The Take That/Robbie situation was different because Robbie had a huge solo career and his songs are better than Take That songs. Also, Noel and Liam are probably too lazy to play two sets This - Robbie sold out 3 nights at Knebworth and Gary Barlow is less stubborn and egotistical than Noel and Liam. It would kill them if either were to play their solo songs and take centre stage
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 22, 2012 10:45:39 GMT -5
I'm sure both Gallaghers would rather eat shit than play tracks from each other's albums.
|
|
|
Post by Bruno on Nov 22, 2012 11:30:56 GMT -5
I'm sure both Gallaghers would rather eat shit than play tracks from each other's albums. lol....True that!
|
|