|
Post by supernovadragon on Apr 2, 2010 9:00:17 GMT -5
Right am bored and I just come up with this idea. Anyway, join in if you wish. It isn't so much a popularity contest, more of a curiosity. Anyway:
Definitely Maybe Digsy's Dinner and Shakermaker (am sorry but if I had to chose two of them. Shakermaker shouldn't have been a single anyway)
(What's The Story)Morning Glory? Swamp Song excepts and Hey Now (bit obvious but if we didn't include them Swamp Song then it would be Hello to be honest)
Be Here Now Be Here Now and I Hope, I Think, I Know (for me, these are both too long and overproduced...can't really listen to them)
The Masterplan The Swamp Song and Going Nowhere (these are just the weakest links in the entire album sadly)
Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants Put Yer Money Where Yer Mouth Is and Fuckin In The Bushes (self explanatory I think)
Heathen Chemistry Force Of Nature and A Quick Peep (Awful production and no place for either of them on this album)
Don't Believe The Truth Mucky Fingers and The Meaning Of Soul (however this one was has hard as Definitely Maybe for me to decide the two)
Dig Out Your Soul Get Off Your High Horse Lady and Ain't Got Nothin (For me both shouldn't be on the album. Can't really stand either to be honest)
So what's yours then?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 2, 2010 12:47:24 GMT -5
shakermaker/digsy dinner (both still brilliant) hey now/shes electric (i dont think the SS extracts really count) the girl in the dirty shirt/fade in out (really dont like these two) going nowhere/the swamp song (easily the worst songs on there) little james/PYMWYMI (ruin a potentially perfect album) she is love/quick peep (howthese made it on instead of SIOL and TYFTGT ill never know) mucky fingers/guess god thinks im abel (difficult becuase theres no filler on DBTT) get off your high horse lady/the nature of reality (i dont mind AGN anymore i mean its a bit shit but kind of like it especially when im pissed off)
|
|
Lectronic
Oasis Roadie
Half the world away
Posts: 164
|
Post by Lectronic on Apr 2, 2010 13:36:46 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe: Digsy's Dinner and Shakermaker WTSMG: If the Swamp Song Interludes don't count, Cast No Shadow and Morning Glory Be Here Now: Magic Pie and Fade-In Out The Masterplan: The Swamp Song and I Am the Walrus Standing on the Shoulder of Giants: Little James and PYMWYMI Heathen Chemistry: All In the Mind and A Quick Peep Don't Believe the Truth: Mucky Fingers and The Meaning of Soul Dig Out Your Soul: High Horse Lady and Ain't Got Nothin' I still love most of these, none the less
|
|
|
Post by AKA... Frozen Eggroll on Apr 2, 2010 14:32:04 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe #1) Digsy's Dinner - It's harmless, but unnecessary at the same time. #2) Shakermaker - It just drags on for too damn long.
(What's the Story) Morning Glory? #1) Hello - IMO, Acquiesce should've been in place of this. #2) Morning Glory - Even though I enjoy listening to it every now and then, it's a bumpy ride all the way through. *Not including Swamp Song interludes
Be Here Now #1) All Around the World (Reprise) - One word: Pointless. #2) It's Gettin' Better (Man!!) - It's a clone of almost every other song on Be Here Now, but for some reason this one had to be over 7 minutes long.
The Masterplan #1) Headshrinker - Like Morning Glory, but worse. #2) I Am the Walrus (Live Cover) - I love the song itself, but I can hardly listen to it.
Standing on the Shoulder of Giants #1) Sunday Morning Call - It's garbage, and no way single material. #2) Fuckin' in the Bushes - Works great as a concert opener, but I skip it every time on the album, and go straight to Go Let It Out.
Heathen Chemistry #1) Better Man - One of the worst Oasis songs out there, and definitely the worst closer to an Oasis album. #2) A Quick Peep - I know Andy had better material, so I don't see how this one was chosen to be on the album.
Don't Believe the Truth #1) Part of the Queue - Unique, but not my type of music. #2) Mucky Fingers - Follows the same fate as POTQ.
Dig Out Your Soul #1) (Get Off Your) High Horse Lady - No, just no. #2) Ain't Got Nothin' - Horrible lyrics, and just a mess of a song.
|
|
|
Post by minx on Apr 2, 2010 14:47:49 GMT -5
Nice thread.
Definitely Maybe:
Digsy's Dinner Shakermaker
I do love these two songs though, they make the album great I think, especially Digsy's.
(What's the Story) Morning Glory?:
Hey Now! Roll with it
Be Here Now:
All Around the World (Reprise) Magic Pie
Standing on the Shoulder of Giants:
I Can See A Liar Little James
Heathen Chemistry:
Better Man Force of Nature
Don't Believe the Truth:
Find this hard because I love every song, but:
Meaning of Soul Lyla
(Love Lyla, just prefer all the others)
Dig Out Your Soul:
Soldier On The Nature of Reality
The Masterplan:
I Am The Walrus Headshrinker
|
|
|
Post by Nyron Nosworthy on Apr 2, 2010 15:40:51 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe 1) Married With Children 2) Up In The Sky
Morning Glory 1) Wonderwall 2) Hey Now
Be Here Now 1) Magic Pie 2) Stand By Me
The Masterplan 1) Going Nowhere 2) Talk Tonight
Standing on the Shoulder of Giants 1) Put Yer Money Where Yer Mouth Is 2) I Can See A Liar
Heathen Chemistry 1) Better Man 2) A Quick Peep
Don't Believe The Truth 1) A Bell Will Ring 2) Guess God Thinks I'm Abel
Dig Out Your Soul 1) Ain't Got Nothing 2) The Nature of Reality
|
|
|
Post by NYR on Apr 2, 2010 15:48:28 GMT -5
definitely maybe: shakermaker married with children
morning glory: the two swamp song excerpts
be here now: all around the world (reprise) magic pie
the masterplan: the swamp song (it's good) to be free
sotsog: little james put yer money where yer mouth is
heathen chemistry: a quick peep force of nature
don't believe the truth: guess god thinks i'm abel the meaning of soul
dig out your soul: ain't got nothing the nature of reality
|
|
|
Post by Cast on Apr 3, 2010 3:23:35 GMT -5
DM: Digsy's Dinner Shakermaker
Neither are bad and actually i think both are great songs and deserve there place on the album. They are just surrounded by classics and just better songs.
MG She's Electric Hey Now!
same as DM
BHN: All Around the World Reprise Its Getting Better Man
Pointless; far to long but has a nice solo.
SOTSOG Little James Put Yer Money Where Yer Mouth Is
both just mediocre tracks. Not the shittest things they've made I think Little James has a nice melody and PYMWYMI while being an average/mediocre rocker and i would have rather had a SOTSOG b-side but it does have nice production.
HC Better Man A Quick Peep
Really I could have add Probably All In the Mind on there for being Noel's worst released song but Better Man is just awful and AQP is pointless
DBTT A Bell Will Ring The Meaning of Soul
Neither are that bad. I've grown to like both over the years serve their place on the album but unlike the first two albums these tracks are of a lower quality.
DOYS Ain't Go Nothin The Nature of Reality
Just a rehash of TMOS but slightly better; killer riff awful melody
TM: I'am the Walrus (live) Swamp Song
Great cover version just a bit long for me and I'd rather have a version that had some strings or a choir; mediocre instrumental sometimes I like it other times i don't. It's great as an opener for a concert but its not something i listen to that often.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 3, 2010 3:52:02 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - Digsy's Dinner, Shakermaker
Morning Glory - Hey Now, Roll With It
Be Here Now - The Girl In The Dirty Shirt, All Around The World (Reprise)
The Masterplan - Swamp Song, I Am The Walrus
SOTSOG - Put Your Money Where Your Mouth It, Little James
Heathen Chemistry - She Is Love, All In The Mind
Don't Believe The Truth - Love Like A Bomb, Keep The Dream Alive
Dig Out Your Soul - Nature Of Reality, Soldier On
I Love pretty much everything the band has put out so making this list was extremely hard especially for the first 4 albums.
|
|
|
Post by hogey on Apr 3, 2010 10:12:55 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - Married with Children, Digsy's Dinner
Morning Glory - Roll With It, Shes Electric
Be Here Now - I Hope, I Think, I Know, All Around The World (Reprise)
The Masterplan - Underneath the Sky, Headshrinker
SOTSOG - Put Your Money Where Your Mouth It, I Can See a Liar
Heathen Chemistry - Hung in a Bad Place, (Probably) All in the Mind
Don't Believe The Truth - Mucky Fingers, Keep the Dream Alive
Dig Out Your Soul - (Get Off Your) High Horse Lady, The Nature of Reality
|
|
|
Post by bwilder on Apr 3, 2010 10:58:59 GMT -5
DM- Shakermaker, Up In The Sky (I quite like Digsy's Dinner... "These could be the best days of our lives" might be the best lyric on the album.)
MG- Hey Now!, The Swamp Song
BHN- Fade In/Out (always skip that one, though it's not terrible.) Magic Pie (boring but love the guitar solo in the live version.)
SOTSOG- Little James (Awwwwwful) PYMWYMI (any song ripping off the Doors sucks)
HC- She Is Love (SHIT), Better Man
DBTT- Let There Be Love (slow and just misses for me) Turn Up The Sun (trudges through mud)
DOYS- Nature Of Reality (I actually don't hate this song, especially the lyrics) GOYHHL (Just a gross song.)
TM- Underneath The Sky, Going Nowhere (french horns!!!!)
|
|
|
Post by mkoasis on Apr 3, 2010 12:49:47 GMT -5
I absolutely LOVE Going Nowhere, I'm surprised to see so many don't like it. Would have been tremendous to hear at the TCT gigs, with the Wired Strings and choir. LEt's see how many of you dislike it after hearing it live... DM: Up in the Sky, Married WithChildren (still great but the two least best) MG: Hey Now, Roll with It (hard to choose but these were the most likely ones) BHN: SBM, BHN (these suffer most from over-kill, but still good) TMP: Swamp Song, I amthe Walrus (apart from these 2, every song on TMP is a fav oasis song) SOTSOG: ICSAL, Little James (even though i really like it - ICSAL is the first OAsis song i don't really like) HC: LBL, FON (moreso the production than the songs themselves) DBTT: TUTS, LLAB (still love these, what a consistent album) DOYS: AGN, TNOR (i like these 2, especially TNOR but there is somethign awkward about it)
|
|
|
Post by Headmaster on Apr 3, 2010 13:00:15 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - Married with Children, Up In The Sky
Morning Glory - Hey Now!, Morning Glory
Be Here Now - Magic Pie, Fade In Out
The Masterplan - The Swamp Song, Headshrinker
Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants - Little James, I Can See a Liar
Heathen Chemistry - Better Man, (Probably) All in the Mind
Don't Believe The Truth - A Bell Will Ring, Keep the Dream Alive
Dig Out Your Soul - Ain't Got Nothing, The Nature of Reality
|
|
|
Post by XTRMNTRSCREAM on Apr 3, 2010 13:16:53 GMT -5
hey now is one of the best things oasis ever did.
|
|
|
Post by flyjeffaplane on Apr 3, 2010 21:15:15 GMT -5
DM- married with children, up in the sky WTSMG- hey now, she's electric BHN- it's gettin better man, be here now MP- going nowhere, talk tonight SOTSOG- put yer money where yer mouth is, i can see a liar HC- better man, force of nature DBTT- mucky fingers, meaning of soul DOYS- to be where there's life, the nature of reality
|
|
|
Post by BlueJay on Apr 4, 2010 0:04:38 GMT -5
funnily enough shakermaker and hey now! are two of my fav oasis songs and they are bith mentioned as one of the worst on their respective albums. hey now is so underrated. very good singing from liam
|
|
|
Post by AKA... Frozen Eggroll on Apr 4, 2010 1:27:58 GMT -5
Not much love for Up In The Sky (amazing song).
|
|
jrs40
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 400
|
Post by jrs40 on Apr 4, 2010 3:46:56 GMT -5
DM- , Bring it on down, digsy's dinner WTSMG- hey now, she's electric BHN- it's gettin better man, reprise MP- I am a walrus, the swamp song SOTSOG- put yer money where yer mouth is, little james HC- better man, she is love DBTT- mucky fingers, meaning of soul DOYS- Get off your high... , Soldier on
|
|
|
Post by Bring It On Dan on Apr 4, 2010 4:21:19 GMT -5
Here we go then, I'm gonna make mine a little different:
Definitely Maybe:
1 - Cigs & Alcho - I'm just bored of it. 2 - Shakermaker - Goes on to long.
What's The Story?
1 - Morning Glory - A bit yawn for me at the minute 2 - Wonderwall - Overplayed
Be Here Now
1- Fade In-Out - Just needless, doesn't add anything for me. 2 - It's Gettin Better Man - Again, too long.
Masterplan
1 - Going Nowhere - Not bad, just my least favourite 2 - Swamp Song - Lovely tune, imagine what it'd be like with lyrics! Missed opportunity if you get me.
Standing On The Shoulder
1 - I Can See A Liar - Average 2 - Put Yer Money Where Yer Mouth Is - Close with Little James, but thisjust takes it.
Heathen Chemistry
1 - Born On A Different Cloud - Boring 2 - Better Man - Similar to Ain't Got Muffins, typical Liam filler.
Don't Believe The Truth
1 - Part Of The Queue 2 - Keep The Dream Alive - Just both average filler.
Dig Out Your Soul
1 - Soldier On - Not bad but not wonderful either 2 - Ain't Got Muffins - Don't dislike it as much as I used too......
|
|
|
Post by bwilder on Apr 4, 2010 10:51:43 GMT -5
Don't get me wrong... I love Going Nowhere and Up In The Sky. I just love them less than the other songs. Oh, I forgot about FON on HC. I replace She Is Love with that one. That's actually one of the few Oasis songs I don't like.
|
|
|
Post by Moorish on Apr 5, 2010 13:16:31 GMT -5
DM: Up In The Sky (still great), Digsy's Dinner (still great)
(WTS)MG: Roll With It (bit by-numbers), Hey Now (still great)
BHN: I Hope, I Think, I Know (B-side level tune, tops), Be Here Now (lyrics are atrocious)
Don't count The Masterplan, is a compilation not an album.
SOTSOG: Little James (lyrics AWFUL), I Can See A Liar
HC: A Quick Peep (utter shit), Better Man (goes nowhere)
DBTT: Lyla (still good), The Meaning Of Soul (still think is way better than gets credit for)
DOYS: Ain't Got Nothin' (Noel was right, it's a B-side), Nature of Reality
|
|
|
Post by Gazza316 on Apr 5, 2010 13:35:26 GMT -5
DM: Up in the Sky Bring It on Down
(WTS)MG: Cast No Shadow Morning Glory
BHN: Fade In-Out Magic Pie
TM: Rockin' Chair Going Nowhere
was the hardest album to decide didn't want to put any, for b-sides, amazing.
SOTSOG: Who Feels Love? Put Yer Money Where Yer Mouth Is
HC: She Is Love Songbird
DBTT: Love Like a Bomb A Bell Will Ring
Very easy to pick, 2 of my least fav songs on my least fav album
DOYS: Soldier On The Nature of Reality
|
|
|
Post by mememe26 on Apr 5, 2010 15:02:37 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe: Shakermaker, Bring It On Down Whats The Story: Morning Glory, Hey Now Be Here Now: Be Here Now, All Around The World (Reprise) SOTSOG: I Can See A Liar, Put Yer Money Where Your Mouth Is Heathen Chemistry: Hung In A Bad Place, A Quick Peep Don't Believe The Truth: Keep The Dream Alive, Part Of The Que Dig Out Your Soul: Ain't Got Nothin', Nature Of Reality The Masterplan: Going Nowhere, Headshrinker
|
|
|
Post by seanppp on Apr 5, 2010 15:44:07 GMT -5
DM: 1. Rock N Roll Star 2. Shakermaker
MG: 1. Hello 2. Roll With It
BHN: 1. Magic Pie 2. It's Gettin' Better Man
SOTSOG: 1. Put Yer Money Where Your Mouth Is 2. Little James
HC: 1. Born On A Different Cloud 2. Better Man
DBTT: 1. The Meaning Of Soul 2. Let There Be Love
DOYS: 1. The Nature Of Reality 2. Soldier On
|
|
|
Post by stevemeister on Apr 6, 2010 2:33:03 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - Shakermaker (I Have this live version from a 94 bootleg that blows my mind though) Married with Children..
Morning Glory - Hey Now, Roll with it
Be Here Now - Stand by Me, TGITDS
The Masterplan - Going Nowhere (just like the song) Half the World Away....why does everyone hate the Swamp Song? it's a rocker
Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants - PYMWYMI, Where did it all go wrong..I hate the fucking pianoooo
Heathen Chemistry - Better Man, (Probably) All in the Mind
Don't Believe The Truth - A quick peep, Keep the Dream Alive
Dig Out Your Soul - Soldier on, The Nature of Reality[/quote]
|
|