|
|
Post by ninestonecowboy on Nov 22, 2017 12:38:22 GMT -5
Beady’s Here Now merged your thread. there's no need for a new one I hope you're wrong though, I hate Arcade Fire, so overrated... Funeral is better than any album Oasis made. They went downhill from there with each album though. At this point, they probably are overrated. Their last album was a bag of shit. Funeral though..what a masterpiece that is. |
|
|
|
Post by Fade In-Out on Nov 22, 2017 12:41:19 GMT -5
Beady’s Here Now merged your thread. there's no need for a new one I hope you're wrong though, I hate Arcade Fire, so overrated... Funeral is better than any album Oasis made. They went downhill from there with each album though. At this point, they probably are overrated. Their last album was a bag of shit. Funeral though..what a masterpiece that is. Funeral is as good as any album oasis made* i'd say, but what an album indeed, every song was perfect like in Morning glory for me. |
|
|
|
Post by The Escapist on Nov 22, 2017 12:41:35 GMT -5
Beady’s Here Now merged your thread. there's no need for a new one I hope you're wrong though, I hate Arcade Fire, so overrated... Funeral is better than any album Oasis made. They went downhill from there with each album though, at this point, they probably are overrated. Their last album was a bag of shit. Funeral though..what a masterpiece that is. I think The Suburbs, Reflektor, Definitely Maybe, and (What's the Story) Morning Glory? are all better albums than Funeral. They're all amazing, though. |
|
|
|
Post by ninestonecowboy on Nov 22, 2017 12:44:06 GMT -5
Funeral is better than any album Oasis made. They went downhill from there with each album though. At this point, they probably are overrated. Their last album was a bag of shit. Funeral though..what a masterpiece that is. Funeral is as good as any album oasis made* i'd say, but what an album indeed, every song was perfect like in Morning glory for me. No album with Digsy's Dinner or a cheeseball song like Rock 'n' Roll Star is as good as Funeral. |
|
|
|
Post by Fade In-Out on Nov 22, 2017 12:49:35 GMT -5
Funeral is as good as any album oasis made* i'd say, but what an album indeed, every song was perfect like in Morning glory for me. No album with Digsy's Dinner or a cheeseball song like Rock 'n' Roll Star is as good as Funeral. I meant it's as good as the best albums oasis made* and better than many other oasis albums  Tbh i think only WTSMG is better than funeral |
|
|
|
Post by ninestonecowboy on Nov 22, 2017 12:51:53 GMT -5
No album with Digsy's Dinner or a cheeseball song like Rock 'n' Roll Star is as good as Funeral. I meant it's as good as the best albums oasis made* and better than many other oasis albums Tbh i think only WTSMG is better than funeral Id agree with that. WTSMG is the only Oasis album i could put alongside Funeral and make a case for it being equal or better, depending on how you looked at it. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 22, 2017 14:13:31 GMT -5
Funeral is as good as any album oasis made* i'd say, but what an album indeed, every song was perfect like in Morning glory for me. No album with Digsy's Dinner or a cheeseball song like Rock 'n' Roll Star is as good as Funeral. Funeral is a masterpiece (in my top 10 ever, with DM and WTSMG too) but c'mon, Rock'n'Roll Star a cheeseball song ? One of the best Oasis tracks ever, wonderful melody, everything is great about that track. |
|
|
|
Post by The Escapist on Nov 22, 2017 14:18:08 GMT -5
No album with Digsy's Dinner or a cheeseball song like Rock 'n' Roll Star is as good as Funeral. Funeral is a masterpiece (in my top 10 ever, with DM and WTSMG too) but c'mon, Rock'n'Roll Star a cheeseball song ? One of the best Oasis tracks ever, wonderful melody, everything is great about that track. It's not cheeseball by any means, but I do have issues with it: - Bass isn't loud enough. - Riff isn't aggressive enough. - Not enough reverb/echo on Liam's voice, which could be a bit more front-and-centre. - The ending should have been shortened like the radio edit. I find it drags to be honest. In contrast, I think Bring it on Down nailed its sound. Like I've said before, a song like Columbia suits that swamp-of-guitars sound. I think Rock 'n' Roll Star should have been a lot more direct and aggressive. |
|
|
|
Post by ninestonecowboy on Nov 22, 2017 14:30:23 GMT -5
No album with Digsy's Dinner or a cheeseball song like Rock 'n' Roll Star is as good as Funeral. Funeral is a masterpiece (in my top 10 ever, with DM and WTSMG too) but c'mon, Rock'n'Roll Star a cheeseball song ? One of the best Oasis tracks ever, wonderful melody, everything is great about that track. It's almost as bad as Rockstar by Nickelback. But seriously, i do like the sentiment and message of Rock 'n' Roll Star, I just find it a bit cheesy and always have done. It's probably the worst track on DM for me along with Live Forever, that's even more cheesy. I'll take songs like Bring It On Down anyday. I actually don't mind Digsy's Dinner despite what i said earlier, it was more of a joke to suggest that a song talking about Lasagna couldn't possibly be better than anything on funeral but really Digsy's Dinner is a fairly inoffensive little tune and fun. |
|
|
|
Post by carlober on Nov 22, 2017 14:43:34 GMT -5
I still have to understand why ninestonecowboy is so active on an Oasis forum, since it seems he doesn't really like anything about the band or the Gallaghers. Roughly 90% of his posts have the only goal of winding people up or bragging about how he's an insider in the music business. The remaining 10% are sensible posts, so I wonder why he doesn't spend more time writing interesting stuff rather than spouting nonsense. God, you're tiresome. Some of the best hits: Well either way you look at it, Live Forever is still quite a cheesy song, along the lines of something Bon Jovi would do. Nirvana were 1000x better than Oasis, that much is for sure. Liam's solo album is going to be so bad because he won't even have the good tunes to hold him up. It'll be just as bad or worse than Beady Eye. His voice is shockingly bad. His voice will probably be even worse now too.  |
|
|
|
Post by tomlivesforever on Nov 22, 2017 14:48:02 GMT -5
Funeral is as good as any album oasis made* i'd say, but what an album indeed, every song was perfect like in Morning glory for me. No album with Digsy's Dinner or a cheeseball song like Rock 'n' Roll Star is as good as Funeral. How is it like Nickleback? How is it cheeseball? Are you just on the wind up now? |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 22, 2017 14:49:33 GMT -5
Really love that song, one of the highlights that makes the ending of the album so good to me Am i the only one totally hearing "Long road to ruin" in the chorus tho?(love that song btw) Love that song. When I got my driving license and first car I had 3 CDs which I played that summer. Oasis - WTSMG, Nirvana - Nevermind and Foo Fighters - Greatest Hits. Good times |
|
|
|
Post by Manualex on Nov 22, 2017 14:51:59 GMT -5
I still have to understand why ninestonecowboy is so active on an Oasis forum, since it seems he doesn't really like anything about the band or the Gallaghers. Roughly 90% of his posts have the only goal of winding people up or bragging about how he's an insider in the music business. The remaining 10% are sensible posts, so I wonder why he doesn't spend more time writing interesting stuff rather than spouting nonsense. God, you're tiresome. Some of the best hits: Well either way you look at it, Live Forever is still quite a cheesy song, along the lines of something Bon Jovi would do. Nirvana were 1000x better than Oasis, that much is for sure. Liam's solo album is going to be so bad because he won't even have the good tunes to hold him up. It'll be just as bad or worse than Beady Eye. His voice is shockingly bad. His voice will probably be even worse now too. add to ignore list and presto no more moaning. |
|
CF83
Oasis Roadie
Posts: 400
|
Post by CF83 on Nov 22, 2017 14:55:23 GMT -5
If Love Is The Law - One of the strongest tracks on the album for me, but unfortunately it remind me of this.....
Still love it though.
|
|
|
|
Post by ninestonecowboy on Nov 22, 2017 14:58:33 GMT -5
I still have to understand why ninestonecowboy is so active on an Oasis forum, since it seems he doesn't really like anything about the band or the Gallaghers. Roughly 90% of his posts have the only goal of winding people up or bragging about how he's an insider in the music business. The remaining 10% are sensible posts, so I wonder why he doesn't spend more time writing interesting stuff rather than spouting nonsense. God, you're tiresome. Some of the best hits: Well either way you look at it, Live Forever is still quite a cheesy song, along the lines of something Bon Jovi would do. Nirvana were 1000x better than Oasis, that much is for sure. Liam's solo album is going to be so bad because he won't even have the good tunes to hold him up. It'll be just as bad or worse than Beady Eye. His voice is shockingly bad. His voice will probably be even worse now too. Firstly i've never bragged about anything. I do work in the music industry, so what? so do thousands and thousands of other people with more "insider" knowledge than me, so it's hardly a big deal. I've only ever tried to pass on information when i see fit if it might be useful. I'm sure 99% of the time, i have no more information than anyone else does. Secondly, i like a lot of Oasis music. I said in this very thread that WTSMG is an excellent album and i'd say it stands up alongside any album by any band pound for pound. I've also stated in previous threads i'm fond of SOTSOG apart from a few tracks, as well as most of DM and a lot of B-sides. Am i an Oasis fan?..probably not as much as most on here but i admire a lot of their work and always keen to hear what new music they are coming out with as solo artists or whatever else. That doesn't mean i shouldn't be on a forum just because i'm not a big fanboy. It would be boring if the forum was a big orgy rather than people having different opinions and maybe listen from a different perspective, like myself who might not be as emotionally invested as others. Also, I do rate Nirvana as a better band than Oasis, and? i'm sure millions of others do too. It's not really that outlandish to say it, they were a great influential band too. It's not like i'm comparing some obscure unknown band to Oasis there. I'll be honest, I did think Liam's album would be a shocker at first but you're being selective there. You could go find plenty of posts where i praised him for working with the writers he did when it was first announced who he was collaborating with... and then i said it would be much better than I initially expected. So don't just be selective, that doesn't tell the full story. |
|
|
|
Post by carlober on Nov 22, 2017 15:08:49 GMT -5
Firstly i've never bragged about anything. I do work in the music industry, so what? so do thousands and thousands of other people with more "insider" knowledge than me, so it's hardly a big deal. I've only ever tried to pass on information when i see fit if it might be useful. I'm sure 99% of the time, i have no more information than anyone else does. Secondly, i like a lot of Oasis music. I said in this very thread that WTSMG is an excellent album and i'd say it stands up alongside any album by any band pound for pound. I've also stated in previous threads i'm fond of SOTSOG apart from a few tracks, as well as most of DM and a lot of B-sides. Am i an Oasis fan?..probably not as much as most on here but i admire a lot of their work and always keen to hear what new music they are coming out with as solo artists or whatever else. That doesn't mean i shouldn't be on a forum just because i'm not a big fanboy. It would be boring if the forum was a big orgy rather than people having different opinions and maybe listen from a different perspective, like myself who might not be as emotionally invested as others. Also, I do rate Nirvana as a better band than Oasis, and? i'm sure millions of others do too. It's really that outlandish to say it, they were a great influential band too. It's not like i'm comparing some obscure unknown band to Oasis there. I'll be honest, I did think Liam's album would be a shocker at first but you're being selective there. You could go find plenty of posts where i praised him for working with the writers he did when it was first announced who he was collaborating with... and then i said it would be much better than I initially expected. So don't just be selective, that doesn't tell the full story. Now here's one of your (pretty rare) sensible posts. Keep 'em like this one please. Most of the time it just looks like you love winding people up and personally speaking I find that kind of behavior pretty annoying. The same applies to the self-righteous and pretentious tone of many of your posts, but hey, maybe it's just me. |
|
|
|
Post by ninestonecowboy on Nov 22, 2017 15:15:59 GMT -5
Firstly i've never bragged about anything. I do work in the music industry, so what? so do thousands and thousands of other people with more "insider" knowledge than me, so it's hardly a big deal. I've only ever tried to pass on information when i see fit if it might be useful. I'm sure 99% of the time, i have no more information than anyone else does. Secondly, i like a lot of Oasis music. I said in this very thread that WTSMG is an excellent album and i'd say it stands up alongside any album by any band pound for pound. I've also stated in previous threads i'm fond of SOTSOG apart from a few tracks, as well as most of DM and a lot of B-sides. Am i an Oasis fan?..probably not as much as most on here but i admire a lot of their work and always keen to hear what new music they are coming out with as solo artists or whatever else. That doesn't mean i shouldn't be on a forum just because i'm not a big fanboy. It would be boring if the forum was a big orgy rather than people having different opinions and maybe listen from a different perspective, like myself who might not be as emotionally invested as others. Also, I do rate Nirvana as a better band than Oasis, and? i'm sure millions of others do too. It's really that outlandish to say it, they were a great influential band too. It's not like i'm comparing some obscure unknown band to Oasis there. I'll be honest, I did think Liam's album would be a shocker at first but you're being selective there. You could go find plenty of posts where i praised him for working with the writers he did when it was first announced who he was collaborating with... and then i said it would be much better than I initially expected. So don't just be selective, that doesn't tell the full story. Now here's one of your (pretty rare) sensible posts. Keep 'em like this one please. Most of the time it just looks like you love winding people up and personally speaking I find that kind of behavior pretty annoying. The same applies to the self-righteous and pretentious tone of many of your posts, but hey, maybe it's just me. Then you're reading them in the wrong tone to how they're intended. There's nothing self-righteous or pretentious about what i write. I merely give my opinion on the topic. It might be a strong worded opinion that goes against the grain sometimes but i don't consider my opinion to hold any more weight than yours or anybody else. Why would i? I'm just a person behind a screen like everyone else. And for that same reason, why would i want to wind up a bunch of people on the internet? Admittedly, i'm a rather blunt person but i'm not going to act like something else for approval. I just enjoy the interaction of this forum when i'm relaxing sometimes. If i was really set out to wind people up, i'd find more interesting places to do it than on a forum talking about Oasis albums. I'm not that bored. |
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Nov 22, 2017 15:17:29 GMT -5
But the disturbing thing about ninestonecowboy is his avatar. If i wanted to look at weird stuff like the Lemon party, i'd go look for it. No need to shove it right there.
|
|
|
|
Post by ninestonecowboy on Nov 22, 2017 15:19:52 GMT -5
But the disturbing thing about ninestonecowboy is his avatar. If i wanted to look at weird stuff like the Lemon party, i'd go look for it. No need to shove it right there. What was weird about my birthday night out? |
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Nov 22, 2017 15:23:40 GMT -5
But the disturbing thing about ninestonecowboy is his avatar. If i wanted to look at weird stuff like the Lemon party, i'd go look for it. No need to shove it right there. What was weird about my birthday night out? Well if you don't know what's weird about the pic, i can't really explain it to you. Isn't it past your bedtime ? |
|
|
|
Post by ninestonecowboy on Nov 22, 2017 15:31:46 GMT -5
What was weird about my birthday night out? Well if you don't know what's weird about the pic, i can't really explain it to you. Isn't it past your bedtime ? Nothing weird about adults in nappies, it can be fairly standard under certain medical conditions. No such thing as bed time in my world. Time is a man-made concept which i try not to live by. The world would turn regardless of clocks and i'm living on the rotation, not an ersatz time zone. |
|
|
|
Post by Hans Gruber on Nov 22, 2017 15:42:04 GMT -5
I live my life for the stars that shine
People say it's just a waste of time
When they said I should feed my head
That to me was just a day in bed...
Thanks.
|
|
|
|
Post by andymorris on Nov 22, 2017 15:44:01 GMT -5
Well if you don't know what's weird about the pic, i can't really explain it to you. Isn't it past your bedtime ? Nothing weird about adults in nappies, it can be fairly standard under certain medical conditions. No such thing as bed time in my world. Time is a man-made concept which i try not to live by. The world would turn regardless of clocks and i'm living on the rotation, not an ersatz time zone. You're really one of a kind arent you. Actually Bedtime is not a man made concept, it's biological thing that happen both in the human and animal world. Roughly every 16 hours, your inner clock tells you you need to rest, so to not die. Bedtime is just a word for a natural need. As for nappies, you probably dont need it (apologies if you do...) But my main concern is 1. Why do you feel the need to wear some and 2. why do you feel the need to show it to the world. I'll leave you with charlie Waffles, i feel this is appropriate |
|
|
|
Post by ninestonecowboy on Nov 22, 2017 16:05:09 GMT -5
Nothing weird about adults in nappies, it can be fairly standard under certain medical conditions. No such thing as bed time in my world. Time is a man-made concept which i try not to live by. The world would turn regardless of clocks and i'm living on the rotation, not an ersatz time zone. You're really one of a kind arent you. Actually Bedtime is not a man made concept, it's biological thing that happen both in the human and animal world. Roughly every 16 hours, your inner clock tells you you need to rest, so to not die. Bedtime is just a word for a natural need. As for nappies, you probably dont need it (apologies if you do...) But my main concern is 1. Why do you feel the need to wear some and 2. why do you feel the need to show it to the world. I'll leave you with charlie Waffles, i feel this is appropriate In that case, going by your theory, your question "isn't it past your bedtime?" simply means "are you tired?" and we both know that's not what you meant. Why do you feel the need to wear the clothes that you like wearing? What's the difference between a nappy and a pair of shorts really? alright, they may be designed for different purposes but both can serve the same purpose too. Some might say that every window is also a door, every end is also a beginning, every weakness is also a strength. Well, every nappy is also a pair of shorts. |
|
|
|
Post by freddy838 on Nov 22, 2017 16:59:57 GMT -5
Firstly i've never bragged about anything. I do work in the music industry, so what? so do thousands and thousands of other people with more "insider" knowledge than me, so it's hardly a big deal. I've only ever tried to pass on information when i see fit if it might be useful. I'm sure 99% of the time, i have no more information than anyone else does. Secondly, i like a lot of Oasis music. I said in this very thread that WTSMG is an excellent album and i'd say it stands up alongside any album by any band pound for pound. I've also stated in previous threads i'm fond of SOTSOG apart from a few tracks, as well as most of DM and a lot of B-sides. Am i an Oasis fan?..probably not as much as most on here but i admire a lot of their work and always keen to hear what new music they are coming out with as solo artists or whatever else. That doesn't mean i shouldn't be on a forum just because i'm not a big fanboy. It would be boring if the forum was a big orgy rather than people having different opinions and maybe listen from a different perspective, like myself who might not be as emotionally invested as others. Also, I do rate Nirvana as a better band than Oasis, and? i'm sure millions of others do too. It's really that outlandish to say it, they were a great influential band too. It's not like i'm comparing some obscure unknown band to Oasis there. I'll be honest, I did think Liam's album would be a shocker at first but you're being selective there. You could go find plenty of posts where i praised him for working with the writers he did when it was first announced who he was collaborating with... and then i said it would be much better than I initially expected. So don't just be selective, that doesn't tell the full story. Now here's one of your (pretty rare) sensible posts. Keep 'em like this one please. Most of the time it just looks like you love winding people up and personally speaking I find that kind of behavior pretty annoying. The same applies to the self-righteous and pretentious tone of many of your posts, but hey, maybe it's just me. Reminds me of that bellend Rollinice |
|
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5
Nov 4, 2024 5:04:30 GMT -5