Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 4, 2015 11:23:56 GMT -5
There'd be a riot in the stadium if Oasis were to play Beady Eye songs. Petrol bombs would be thrown on the first song, then police on horseback would appear when 'The Roller Uh Uh Uh Uh' commenced and eventually tanks and the military would be called in at the strike of the first chord of The Beat Goes On.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 4, 2015 19:22:43 GMT -5
Intro: Fuckin' In The Bushes
1. Acquiesce 2. Some Might Say 3. Supersonic 4. Listen Up 5. D'You Know What I Mean ? 6. Cigarettes And Alcohol 7. Slide Away 8. Morning Glory
9. Whatever 10. The Masterplan 11. Wonderwall 12. All Around The World 13. Cast No Shadow
14. Half The World Away (acoustic) 15. The Masterplan (acoustic) 16. The Importance of Being Idle (acoustic) 17. Songbird (acoustic)
18. Stand By Me 19. Live Forever 20. Champagne Supernova 21. Gas Panic ! 22. Don't Look Back In Anger 23. Rock'n'Roll Star 24. It's Getting Better (Man!!) (20 minutes long)
If only...
|
|
|
Post by russiangenius on Dec 6, 2015 3:44:23 GMT -5
I see that most people prefer include songs like Gas Panic!, Some Might Say, AATW, Listen Up and smth like this. Are you fookin' serious?! SMS would be sound like Roll With It in 2009 but it was horrible that time so what would be nowadays? What about Gas Panic! in 2015? Like Lyla during DOYS-tour? Okay, maybe there wouldn't be HFB and BE songs 'cause it's Oasis reunion, not BE+HFB. But... I like lyrics in MOS, it's great end of concert's first part + Liam's voice is okay with this song. The most important thing in this imaginative gig is RKid' voice, Noel would make an Oasis reunion without L (it would be great, gig like MTV Unplugged) but again... 25 songs - whooh
P.S I prefer acoustic version of DLBIA, it's amazing, it would be more comfortable for last Oasis concert
|
|
|
Post by The Milkman & The Riverman on Dec 6, 2015 13:20:02 GMT -5
I wish the last Oasis concert would be in someone's house , at the party for a 50 people or something like that. We'd just seen the pictures and one 13 seconds long clip of rich drunk motherfuckers dancing to Rock N Roll Star. That's kinda my fetish for an Oasis reunion. I'd love something like that to happen like tomorrow.
|
|
|
Post by liamgallagher1992 on Dec 6, 2015 14:12:17 GMT -5
One thing is for sure - Liam's voice isn't as bad as your English, Nor Russia
|
|
|
Post by mimmihopps on Dec 6, 2015 14:42:16 GMT -5
Sorry to OP, but this idea will never work. Why the hell will they play NGHFB and Beady Eye's songs at Oasis "last" gig? Just like matt said, it'll be a riot. One thing is for sure - Liam's voice isn't as bad as your English, Nor Russia At least us, non native English speakers on this forum always post in English while many of us speak multiple languages and we don't complain about it as being members on an English operated forum, so you gotta tolerate our "bad" English.
|
|
|
Post by Mean Mrs. Mustard on Dec 6, 2015 15:05:34 GMT -5
One thing is for sure - Liam's voice isn't as bad as your English, Nor Russia So how many languages do you speak fluently? A lot, presumably, otherwise you wouldn't be so arrogant and disrespectful about the way others speak. At least he tries, and it's understandable, so what's your problem even? Also, who are you even talking to? What do you mean with "Nor Russia?, of which "nor" shouldn't even be with a capital N? And what do you mean with "Russia"? That Russia's English isn't great? In that case it should be "nor Russia's". Don't complain about other people's English if you can't even construct a fully correct sentence yourself. You're welcome.
|
|
|
Post by matt on Dec 6, 2015 17:11:27 GMT -5
One thing is for sure - Liam's voice isn't as bad as your English, Nor Russia So how many languages do you speak fluently? A lot, presumably, otherwise you wouldn't be so arrogant and disrespectful about the way others speak. At least he tries, and it's understandable, so what's your problem even? Also, who are you even talking to? What do you mean with "Nor Russia?, of which "nor" shouldn't even be with a capital N? And what do you mean with "Russia"? That Russia's English isn't great? In that case it should be "nor Russia's". Don't complain about other people's English if you can't even construct a fully correct sentence yourself. You're welcome. And what is with the siege mentality from those who can't stand Liam being criticised? It's pathetic. I can only imagine there is some cult like group of people wearing shades and parkas battening down the hatches of their headquarters, and supplying themselves with an ammunition of plums, ready to take down those who dare to slate 'Our Kid' (a formal address to their fantastic leader).
|
|
|
Post by Aman on Dec 6, 2015 17:30:11 GMT -5
Forget about the bloke's English, what's with that opinion of Some Might Say!
Scandalous.
|
|
|
Post by Mean Mrs. Mustard on Dec 6, 2015 17:30:17 GMT -5
So how many languages do you speak fluently? A lot, presumably, otherwise you wouldn't be so arrogant and disrespectful about the way others speak. At least he tries, and it's understandable, so what's your problem even? Also, who are you even talking to? What do you mean with "Nor Russia?, of which "nor" shouldn't even be with a capital N? And what do you mean with "Russia"? That Russia's English isn't great? In that case it should be "nor Russia's". Don't complain about other people's English if you can't even construct a fully correct sentence yourself. You're welcome. And what is with the siege mentality from those who can't stand Liam being criticised? It's pathetic. I can only imagine there is some cult like group of people wearing shades and parkas battening down the hatches of their headquarters, and supplying themselves with an ammunition of plums, ready to take down those who dare to slate 'Our Kid' (a formal address to their fantastic leader). Oh God, this made me laugh. Finally someone who dares to say it though! Especially those who think it's cool to behave like Liam's image from 1996. Those are the most hilarious.
|
|
|
Post by tatomoon on Dec 6, 2015 18:03:53 GMT -5
I see that most people prefer include songs like Gas Panic!, Some Might Say, AATW, Listen Up and smth like this. Are you fookin' serious?! SMS would be sound like Roll With It in 2009 but it was horrible that time so what would be nowadays? What about Gas Panic! in 2015? Like Lyla during DOYS-tour? Okay, maybe there wouldn't be HFB and BE songs 'cause it's Oasis reunion, not BE+HFB. But... I like lyrics in MOS, it's great end of concert's first part + Liam's voice is okay with this song. The most important thing in this imaginative gig is RKid' voice, Noel would make an Oasis reunion without L (it would be great, gig like MTV Unplugged) but again... 25 songs - whooh P.S I prefer acoustic version of DLBIA, it's amazing, it would be more comfortable for last Oasis concert I see what you mean, but would argue that Liam's voice is slightly better now than in 2009 as he has not had to do any screaming or stretching of his vocals in big arena or stadium gigs. In fact, he's not had to do much singing at all for about 18 months. I don't think it's unreasonable to suggest he'd be able to sing a song like Gas Panic or Some Might Say for one gig. Also I think you have a good point about Don't Look Back in Anger, for a final gig it might be better to have the more sentimental acoustic version, I personally prefer the electric version though and especially how it was performed around 2000. A nice, if pointless, discussion nonetheless.
|
|
|
Post by liamgallagher1992 on Dec 11, 2015 7:50:36 GMT -5
So how many languages do you speak fluently? A lot, presumably, otherwise you wouldn't be so arrogant and disrespectful about the way others speak. At least he tries, and it's understandable, so what's your problem even? Also, who are you even talking to? What do you mean with "Nor Russia?, of which "nor" shouldn't even be with a capital N? And what do you mean with "Russia"? That Russia's English isn't great? In that case it should be "nor Russia's". Don't complain about other people's English if you can't even construct a fully correct sentence yourself. You're welcome. And what is with the siege mentality from those who can't stand Liam being criticised? It's pathetic. I can only imagine there is some cult like group of people wearing shades and parkas battening down the hatches of their headquarters, and supplying themselves with an ammunition of plums, ready to take down those who dare to slate 'Our Kid' (a formal address to their fantastic leader). Yawn. God forbid there are people wanting to defend Liam Gallagher on an Oasis forum. There is far more on here that get offended by anything directed at Noel, or even anyone who speaks badly about Oasis. In fact I seriously wonder if this is the only band where the lead singer is slagged to shit while other singers and bands get praise for all of their great attributes. The saddest thing is how people on here now hide so much behind their opinions too. For example Mr Lennon will say something constructive like "Liam's voice needs a good producer" while he will like anything under the sun calling his voice utter shit. Too much brown nosing on here now.
|
|
|
Post by matt on Dec 11, 2015 12:32:46 GMT -5
And what is with the siege mentality from those who can't stand Liam being criticised? It's pathetic. I can only imagine there is some cult like group of people wearing shades and parkas battening down the hatches of their headquarters, and supplying themselves with an ammunition of plums, ready to take down those who dare to slate 'Our Kid' (a formal address to their fantastic leader). Yawn. God forbid there are people wanting to defend Liam Gallagher on an Oasis forum. There is far more on here that get offended by anything directed at Noel, or even anyone who speaks badly about Oasis. In fact I seriously wonder if this is the only band where the lead singer is slagged to shit while other singers and bands get praise for all of their great attributes. The saddest thing is how people on here now hide so much behind their opinions too. For example Mr Lennon will say something constructive like "Liam's voice needs a good producer" while he will like anything under the sun calling his voice utter shit. Too much brown nosing on here now. Defending him is one thing, but the siege mentality when it resorts to personal insults for a criticism of Liam is completely different. Seriously, who gives a fuck? Why on earth some people on here like yourself take criticism of Liam as a personal insult is beyond me. I could almost see the point if you were bezzie mates with him or if you yourself are actually Liam? Most of us don't care for the Gallaghers personally so we judge them on their music and they will both continue to be judged on their output and that is subjective, which is the beauty of music. And if it ain't good enough they will rightly get rounded upon - this ain't a fucking football club supporters group or political party where there are tribal loyalties. I just can't believe you attempt to reduce music to such tribalism - it's just weird and cheapens music. After all, God forbid anyone judging the music on its own merits here.... If I say he has a shit voice these days, then how is that any less legitimate an opinion to express than praise of him which we all do (erm, we are Oasis fans for a reason)? Do we have to blindly follow him and praise everything he does like he's a cult leader - it seems that way, because you've taken offence at a not-that-controversial criticism of Liam and personally insulted the guy's English skills. When some folk outright say he has a shit voice that sounds like a rusty chainsaw these days, then we are judging the music which we have listened to - we're not having a personal dig at him. Just like when we praise him for his peak performances on Oasis albums - we're judging his musical output, not him personally. And I think he is a legend on the whole because of his contributions over the years. But that doesn't mean we can't criticise his output today, Likewise, I think Paul McCartney can't sing these days, but that doesn't mean I don't think he's a legend who was the brains behind Sgt Pepper (or Sgt Gayboy or whatever you call The Beatles...) Again, God forbid anyone who discusses the music on here...... If we start shouting that he is a knobhead who walks around like a pissed chimp with a nappy full of porridge, then yeah, you have grounds to claim that we are veering off into unnecessary territory on a music discussion (and please, I am just merely using that analogy as an example). But then again, who cares as its only the music discussion that matters is it not?
|
|
|
Post by liamgallagher1992 on Dec 11, 2015 13:59:38 GMT -5
Yawn. God forbid there are people wanting to defend Liam Gallagher on an Oasis forum. There is far more on here that get offended by anything directed at Noel, or even anyone who speaks badly about Oasis. In fact I seriously wonder if this is the only band where the lead singer is slagged to shit while other singers and bands get praise for all of their great attributes. The saddest thing is how people on here now hide so much behind their opinions too. For example Mr Lennon will say something constructive like "Liam's voice needs a good producer" while he will like anything under the sun calling his voice utter shit. Too much brown nosing on here now. Defending him is one thing, but the siege mentality when it resorts to personal insults for a criticism of Liam is completely different. Seriously, who gives a fuck? Why on earth some people on here like yourself take criticism of Liam as a personal insult is beyond me. I could almost see the point if you were bezzie mates with him or if you yourself are actually Liam? Most of us don't care for the Gallaghers personally so we judge them on their music and they will both continue to be judged on their output and that is subjective, which is the beauty of music. And if it ain't good enough they will rightly get rounded upon - this ain't a fucking football club supporters group or political party where there are tribal loyalties. I just can't believe you attempt to reduce music to such tribalism - it's just weird and cheapens music. After all, God forbid anyone judging the music on its own merits here.... If I say he has a shit voice these days, then how is that any less legitimate an opinion to express than praise of him which we all do (erm, we are Oasis fans for a reason)? Do we have to blindly follow him and praise everything he does like he's a cult leader - it seems that way, because you've taken offence at a not-that-controversial criticism of Liam and personally insulted the guy's English skills. When some folk outright say he has a shit voice that sounds like a rusty chainsaw these days, then we are judging the music which we have listened to - we're not having a personal dig at him. Just like when we praise him for his peak performances on Oasis albums - we're judging his musical output, not him personally. And I think he is a legend on the whole because of his contributions over the years. But that doesn't mean we can't criticise his output today, Likewise, I think Paul McCartney can't sing these days, but that doesn't mean I don't think he's a legend who was the brains behind Sgt Pepper (or Sgt Gayboy or whatever you call The Beatles...) Again, God forbid anyone who discusses the music on here...... If we start shouting that he is a knobhead who walks around like a pissed chimp with a nappy full of porridge, then yeah, you have grounds to claim that we are veering off into unnecessary territory on a music discussion (and please, I am just merely using that analogy as an example). But then again, who cares as its only the music discussion that matters is it not? The Troller thread was clearly lost on someone
|
|
|
Post by mimmihopps on Dec 11, 2015 14:08:46 GMT -5
If you love some band/singer/musician, you should be able to deal with criticism as well.
|
|
|
Post by matt on Dec 11, 2015 14:17:26 GMT -5
Defending him is one thing, but the siege mentality when it resorts to personal insults for a criticism of Liam is completely different. Seriously, who gives a fuck? Why on earth some people on here like yourself take criticism of Liam as a personal insult is beyond me. I could almost see the point if you were bezzie mates with him or if you yourself are actually Liam? Most of us don't care for the Gallaghers personally so we judge them on their music and they will both continue to be judged on their output and that is subjective, which is the beauty of music. And if it ain't good enough they will rightly get rounded upon - this ain't a fucking football club supporters group or political party where there are tribal loyalties. I just can't believe you attempt to reduce music to such tribalism - it's just weird and cheapens music. After all, God forbid anyone judging the music on its own merits here.... If I say he has a shit voice these days, then how is that any less legitimate an opinion to express than praise of him which we all do (erm, we are Oasis fans for a reason)? Do we have to blindly follow him and praise everything he does like he's a cult leader - it seems that way, because you've taken offence at a not-that-controversial criticism of Liam and personally insulted the guy's English skills. When some folk outright say he has a shit voice that sounds like a rusty chainsaw these days, then we are judging the music which we have listened to - we're not having a personal dig at him. Just like when we praise him for his peak performances on Oasis albums - we're judging his musical output, not him personally. And I think he is a legend on the whole because of his contributions over the years. But that doesn't mean we can't criticise his output today, Likewise, I think Paul McCartney can't sing these days, but that doesn't mean I don't think he's a legend who was the brains behind Sgt Pepper (or Sgt Gayboy or whatever you call The Beatles...) Again, God forbid anyone who discusses the music on here...... If we start shouting that he is a knobhead who walks around like a pissed chimp with a nappy full of porridge, then yeah, you have grounds to claim that we are veering off into unnecessary territory on a music discussion (and please, I am just merely using that analogy as an example). But then again, who cares as its only the music discussion that matters is it not? The Troller thread was clearly lost on someone Yeah right.... "troller thread".
|
|
|
Post by Mean Mrs. Mustard on Dec 11, 2015 14:28:28 GMT -5
Good points and agree with it all. Matt, you're saying exactly what I think, but can't describe good enough in English.
|
|
|
Post by matt on Dec 11, 2015 17:44:19 GMT -5
Good points and agree with it all. Matt, you're saying exactly what I think, but can't describe good enough in English. And as I suggest, we're really not that thick to believe that his play pen thread full of diatribes against The Beatles and their inferiority to Liam Gallagher's songwriting was 'trolling'. Hilarious and pathetic, but then again he has history of insulting members of this board as he cant see differing viewpoints from being blinded by the sun that apparently shines out of Liam's arse, so this ain't new.
|
|
|
Post by noelygthelegend on Dec 13, 2015 11:06:44 GMT -5
liamgallagher1992 so your seriously gonna suggest that liam's voice would be great if they did an oasis reunion? Mate I like liam's voice just as much as the next person his vocals on BHN were immense and its what made songs like DGA so good but his voice now just isn't what it used be and the thing will the good English was ridiculous.
|
|
|
Post by dontlookback82 on Dec 13, 2015 16:41:19 GMT -5
1 Hello 2 Roll With It 3 Supersonic 4 Lyla 5 The Shock Of The Lightning 6 Morning Glory 7 Columbia 8 D'you Know What I Mean? 9 Go Let It Out 10 Live Forever 11 Songbird 12 Wonderwall 13 The Masterplan 14 Don't Look Back In Anger 16 Cigarettes & Alcohol 17 Acquiesce
Encore 18 Let There Be Love 19 Champagne Supernova 20 Rock 'n' Roll Star
|
|
|
Post by liamgallagher1992 on Dec 14, 2015 13:41:54 GMT -5
liamgallagher1992 so your seriously gonna suggest that liam's voice would be great if they did an oasis reunion? Mate I like liam's voice just as much as the next person his vocals on BHN were immense and its what made songs like DGA so good but his voice now just isn't what it used be and the thing will the good English was ridiculous. I'd rather hear Liam singing on 11 Noel written tracks than Noel. I don't think Noels voice is powerful or interesting enough for a whole album. I didn't understand the last part of your paragraph.
|
|
|
Post by liamgallagher1992 on Dec 14, 2015 13:59:19 GMT -5
Good points and agree with it all. Matt, you're saying exactly what I think, but can't describe good enough in English. And as I suggest, we're really not that thick to believe that his play pen thread full of diatribes against The Beatles and their inferiority to Liam Gallagher's songwriting was 'trolling'. Hilarious and pathetic, but then again he has history of insulting members of this board as he cant see differing viewpoints from being blinded by the sun that apparently shines out of Liam's arse, so this ain't new. I'm flattered you know who I am, because I don't have a clue who you are. To cut a long story short, there was a bloke called deasy55 on here. I did that thread and a few like it because he was boring the life out of me. Any posts I've done since those years, its clear to see I'm very balanced in my viewpoints towards Noel. I love him. In fact I defend him as much as anyone on here has done to friends and whoever harshly criticises him. Hope this clears your conspiracy theories up, and thank you (like i said to Let It Bleed) for going back into a 2011 thread and showing so much attention. Have a good Christmas everyone
|
|
|
Post by matt on Dec 14, 2015 14:42:56 GMT -5
And as I suggest, we're really not that thick to believe that his play pen thread full of diatribes against The Beatles and their inferiority to Liam Gallagher's songwriting was 'trolling'. Hilarious and pathetic, but then again he has history of insulting members of this board as he cant see differing viewpoints from being blinded by the sun that apparently shines out of Liam's arse, so this ain't new. I'm flattered you know who I am, because I don't have a clue who you are. To cut a long story short, there was a bloke called deasy55 on here. I did that thread and a few like it because he was boring the life out of me. Word of advice - don't ever become a lawyer. Nobody's buying it mate, admit you fucked up.
|
|
|
Post by noelygthelegend on Dec 14, 2015 14:59:13 GMT -5
liamgallagher1992 so your seriously gonna suggest that liam's voice would be great if they did an oasis reunion? Mate I like liam's voice just as much as the next person his vocals on BHN were immense and its what made songs like DGA so good but his voice now just isn't what it used be and the thing will the good English was ridiculous. I'd rather hear Liam singing on 11 Noel written tracks than Noel. I don't think Noels voice is powerful or interesting enough for a whole album. I didn't understand the last part of your paragraph. I was saying I think his voice made sings like dint go away excellent rather than very good but now his voice isn't what it was. The other bit was why did you insult people's English?
|
|
|
Post by The-Ghost-Dancer on Dec 14, 2015 15:09:52 GMT -5
this here fellow forum members is my dream setlist for a last concert or 1 off reunion show its 30 songs long cos FITB dont count. If they got back together for a one off show the prices for tickets would be skyhigh so i would want me fuckin moneys worth if i was lucky enough to blag a ticket
___________________________________________________________
Fucking in the bushes Rock n Roll star Acquiesce The Shock Of the lightening Supersonic Columbia Hello My Big Mouth Falling down Fade in-out
Noel Acoustic slot
The Importance of being idle The Masterplan Take me away Sittin here in silence on my own
Bring it on down Morning Glory Do you know what i mean Dont go away go let it out Cloudburst Gas panic Cigarettes & Alcohol Round Are way
1st encore
Champagne Supernova Some Might Say Rockin Chair Roll it over
2nd encore
Slide away live forever Dont Look back in anger Lets all make believe (liam on verse dutys both on the chorus)
|
|