|
Post by The Crimson Rambler on Jun 27, 2019 17:55:42 GMT -5
Seeing as I've made a ranking thread for Noel I think it's only fair I do one for Liam too.
Liam Post Oasis - Favourite to Least 8.5/10 1) Flick of the Finger [Liam Gallagher, Gem Archer, Andy Bell] 2) Wall of Glass [Liam Gallagher, Greg Kurstin, Andrew Wyatt, Michael Tighe, Andrew Sidney Fox]
8/10 3) Greedy Soul [Liam Gallagher] 4) The Roller [Gem Archer]
7.5/10 5) Come Back To Me [Liam Gallagher, Greg Kurstin, Andrew Wyatt] 6) I’ve All I Need [Liam Gallagher] 7) Sons of the Stage [World of Twist cover] [Gordon King, Tony Ogdon] 8) Bring the Light [Liam Gallagher]
7/10 9) Four Letter Word [Andy Bell] 10) The River [Liam Gallagher, Andrew Wyatt] 11) Second Bite of the Apple [Gem Archer] 12) Shine a Light [Liam Gallagher] 13) Shockwave [Liam Gallagher, Greg Kurstin, Andrew Wyatt] 14) Bold [Liam Gallagher] 15) Chinatown [Andrew Wyatt, Michael Tighe] 16) For What It’s Worth [Liam Gallagher, Simon Jons]
6.5/10 17) Soul Love [Liam Gallagher] 18) Start Anew [Liam Gallagher] 19) Paper Crown [Andrew Wyatt, Michael Tighe] 20) You Better Run [Liam Gallagher] 21) For Anyone [Liam Gallagher] 22) When I’m In Need [Liam Gallagher, Iain Archer] 23) Universal Gleam [Liam Gallagher]
6/10 24) In the Bubble With a Bullet [Gem Archer] 25) I Get By [Liam Gallagher] 26) Standing On the Edge of the Noise [Gem Archer] 27) I’m Just Saying [Andy Bell] 28) Evil Eye [Liam Gallagher] 29) Wigwam [Liam Gallagher] 30) Face the Crowd [Andy Bell] 31) White Smoke [Unreleased Instrumental] [?] 32) The Morning Son [Liam Gallagher] 33) Three Ring Circus [Gem Archer] 34) Doesn’t Have To Be That Way [Liam Gallagher, Greg Kurstin, Andrew Wyatt]
5.5/10 35) The World Is Not Set In Stone [Liam Gallagher] 36) Soon Come Tomorrow [Andy Bell] 37) Dreaming of Some Space [Andy Bell]
5/10 38) Millionaire [Andy Bell] 39) Man of Misery [Liam Gallagher] 40) Beatles and Stones [Liam Gallagher] 41) All My People/All Mankind [Liam Gallagher] 42) World Outside My Room [Andy Bell]
4.5/10 43) Kill for a Dream [Andy Bell] 44) Don’t Brother Me [Liam Gallagher] 45) Iz Rite [Gem Archer] 46) Yellow Tail [Unreleased Instrumental] [Gem Archer] 47) The Beat Goes On [Andy Bell] 48) Wind Up Dream [Gem Archer]
3.5/10 49) Two of a Kind [?] 50) Girls In Uniform [Andy Bell]
3/10 51) Ballroom Figured [Gem Archer] 52) Off At the Next Exit [Gem Archer] 53) I Never Want To Be Like You [Liam Gallagher] 54) Back After the Break [Gem Archer]
Beady Eye: DGSS LP: 5.88/10 DGSS Era: 5.68/10 BE LP: 5.91/10 BE Era: 5.42/10
Solo: AYW LP: 7.04/10 AYW Era: 6.57/10 WM?WN? LP: ? WM?WN? Era: ?
|
|
|
Post by betinho on Jun 29, 2019 4:57:17 GMT -5
BE bonustracks and b-sides are possibly the best Beady Eye’s songs 😕
|
|
|
Post by Rolo on Jun 29, 2019 5:17:56 GMT -5
Off At The Next Exit gets a 3/10? Wow.
|
|
|
Post by rockrevival on Jun 29, 2019 5:27:44 GMT -5
Wall of Glass better than I've All I Need? I get it that it was his debut song, but it's soooooo hyped up. It's a generic song that goes nowhere whereas IAIN is a superb composition from start to finish. It has great and retrospective lyrics, multiple hooks and a killer chorus(Noel's condition). It rivals even Noel's songs in terms of structure and general vibe. To me it's the greatest Gallagher song in a long,long time. And bear in mind that Noel has written at least 5 killer Oasis-level tunes in the last 10 years
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 29, 2019 5:32:07 GMT -5
Wall of Glass is a great song. Fact.
|
|
|
Post by The Crimson Rambler on Jun 29, 2019 15:13:21 GMT -5
BE bonustracks and b-sides are possibly the best Beady Eye’s songs 😕 Off At The Next Exit gets a 3/10? Wow. I've read lots of posts on here suggesting that many of the best BE tracks were the bonus tracks but 'Evil Eye', ''The World Is Not Set In Stone' & 'Dream of Some Space' aside they don't do it for me. I find them to be incredibly boring. The only positive I can think of is that they're pretty tastefully done. Personally I wouldn't even have had bothered recording them though it's nice to hear that others like them. Wall of Glass better than I've All I Need? I get it that it was his debut song, but it's soooooo hyped up. It's a generic song that goes nowhere whereas IAIN is a superb composition from start to finish. It has great and retrospective lyrics, multiple hooks and a killer chorus(Noel's condition). It rivals even Noel's songs in terms of structure and general vibe. To me it's the greatest Gallagher song in a long,long time. And bear in mind that Noel has written at least 5 killer Oasis-level tunes in the last 10 years I believe it's a very common opinion that 'Wall of Glass' is the better tune but I'm a big fan of 'I've All I Need' and I consider it to be one of the best tracks Liam has written to date. Maybe it'll be in that 8/10 category at some point but 7.5/10 is how I'm feeling about it right now and I consider that a very respectable score indeed.
|
|
|
Post by Nyron Nosworthy on Jun 29, 2019 16:32:59 GMT -5
8.5/10 Flick of the Finger
8/10 Four Letter Word The Morning Son
7.5/10 Come Back To Me I’ve All I Need Shockwave Start Anew You Better Run
7/10 For What It’s Worth Soul Love The World Is Not Set In Stone Wigwam
6.5/10 Sons of the Stage Bold Evil Eye Greedy Soul I’m Just Saying Man of Misery
6/10 The Roller Back After the Break Millionaire Paper Crown The River Wall of Glass
5.5/10 Three Ring Circus Ballroom Figured Face the Crowd Off At the Next Exit World Outside My Room
5/10 The Beat Goes On Universal Gleam All My People/All Mankind Doesn’t Have To Be That Way I Never Want To Be Like You In the Bubble With a Bullet When I’m In Need
4.5/10 Kill for a Dream Shine a Light Two of a Kind I Get By Girls In Uniform
4/10 Yellow Tail Bring the Light Standing On the Edge of the Noise
3.5/10 Wind Up Dream Soon Come Tomorrow Dreaming of Some Space
3/10 White Smoke For Anyone Beatles and Stones Iz Rite
2.5/10 Chinatown Second Bite of the Apple
2/10 Don’t Brother Me
|
|
|
Post by The Crimson Rambler on Nov 6, 2020 18:09:20 GMT -5
BEADY EYE DIFFERENT GEAR, STILL SPEEDING Four Letter Word 6/10 [Andy Bell]Millionaire 4/10 [Andy Bell]The Roller 7/10 [Gem Archer]Beatles and Stones 5/10 [Liam Gallagher]Wind Up Dream 4/10 [Gem Archer]Bring the Light 6/10 [Liam Gallagher]For Anyone 6/10 [Liam Gallagher]Kill for a Dream 4/10 [Andy Bell]Standing on the Edge of the Noise 5/10 [Gem Archer]Wigwam 4/10 [Liam Gallagher]Three Ring Circus 4/10 [Gem Archer]The Beat Goes On 3/10 [Andy Bell]The Morning Son 5/10 [Liam Gallagher]
Average Song Rating — 4.8/10 Album Rating — ★★☆☆☆ World Outside My Room 4/10 [Andy Bell] Two of a Kind 4/10 [?] Man of Misery 4/10 [Liam Gallagher] In the Bubble with a Bullet 6/10 [Gem Archer]
BE Flick of the Finger 8/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andy Bell/Gem Archer]Soul Love 6/10 [Liam Gallagher]Face the Crowd 5/10 [Andy Bell]Second Bite of the Apple 6/10 [Gem Archer]Soon Come Tomorrow 4/10 [Andy Bell]Iz Rite 3/10 [Gem Archer]I’m Just Saying 5/10 [Andy Bell]Don’t Brother Me 5/10 [Liam Gallagher]Shine a Light 6/10 [Liam Gallagher]Ballroom Figured 3/10 [Gem Archer]Start Anew 5/10 [Liam Gallagher]Average Song Rating — 5.09/10 Album Rating — ★★☆☆☆ Dreaming of Some Space 5/10 [Andy Bell] The World’s Not Set In Stone 5/10 [Liam Gallagher] Back After the Break 3/10 [Gem Archer] Off at the Next Exit 3/10 [Gem Archer] Girls in Uniform 2/10 [Andy Bell] Evil Eye 4/10 [Liam Gallagher]
Average Song Ratings
10/10 — 09/10 — 08/10 — 17/10 — 16/10 — 75/10 — 94/10 — 103/10 — 52/10 — 11/10 — 0
Average — 4.7/10 Songwriter Average Ratings
Liam Gallagher — 5.3/10 [13 songs]Gem Archer — 4.7/10 [11 songs]Andy Bell — 4.5/10 [11 songs]
LIAM GALLAGHER
AS YOU WERE Wall of Glass 8/10 [Liam Gallagher/Greg Kurstin/Andrew Wyatt/Michael Tighe/Andrew Sidney Fox]Bold 7/10 [Liam Gallagher]Greedy Soul 7/10 [Liam Gallagher]Paper Crown 6/10 [Andrew Wyatt/Michael Tighe]For What It’s Worth 6/10 [Liam Gallagher/Simon Jons]When I’m in Need 6/10 [Liam Gallagher/Iain Archer]You Better Run 6/10 [Liam Gallagher]I Get By 6/10 [Liam Gallagher]Chinatown 6/10 [Andrew Wyatt/Michael Tighe]Come Back to Me 7/10 [Liam Gallagher/Greg Kurstin/Andrew Wyatt]Universal Gleam 6/10 [Liam Gallagher]I’ve All I Need 7/10 [Liam Gallagher]Average Song Rating — 6.50/10 Album Rating — ★★★☆☆ Doesn’t Have to Be That Way 5/10 [Liam Gallagher/Greg Kurstin/Andrew Wyatt] All My People / All Mankind 3/10 [Liam Gallagher] I Never Wanna Be Like You 3/10 [Liam Gallagher]
WHY ME? WHY NOT.
Shockwave 6/10 [Liam Gallagher/Greg Kurstin/Andrew Wyatt]One of Us 7/10 [Liam Gallagher/Damon McMahon/Andrew Wyatt]Once 6/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt]Now that I’ve Found You 7/10 [Liam Gallagher/Simon Aldred]Halo 5/10 [Liam Gallagher/Greg Kurstin/Andrew Wyatt]Why Me? Why Not. 5/10 [Liam Gallagher/Simon Aldred]Be Still 5/10 [Liam Gallagher/Greg Kurstin/Andrew Wyatt]Alright Now 4/10 [Liam Gallagher/Damon McMahon/Andrew Wyatt]Meadow 5/10 [Liam Gallagher/Greg Kurstin/Andrew Wyatt]The River 8/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt]Gone 6/10 [Liam Gallagher/Michael Tighe/Andrew Wyatt]
Average Song Rating — 5.82/10 Album Rating — ★★★☆☆ Invisible Sun 7/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt] Misunderstood 4/10 [Liam Gallagher/Simon Aldred] Glimmer 3/10 [Liam Gallagher/Michael Tighe/Andrew Wyatt/Constantin Veis/Alex Veis] All You're Dreaming Of 3/10 [Liam Gallagher/Simon Aldred]
C'MON YOU KNOW More Power 5/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt]Diamonds In The Dark 6/10 [Liam Gallagher/Michael Tighe/Andrew Wyatt]Don't Go Halfway 3/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt/Dan McDougal/Mike Moor]C'Mon You Know 5/10 [Liam Gallagher]Too Good For Giving Up 5/10 [Liam Gallagher/Simon Aldred]Was Not Meant To Be 4/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt]Everything's Electric 7/10 [Liam Gallagher/Greg Kurstin/Dave Grohl/Friedrich Kunath]The World Is In Need 5/10 [Liam Gallagher]Moscow Rules 3/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt/Ezra Koenig]I'm Free 4/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt]Better Days 7/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt/Michael Tighe/Gustav Weber Vernet/Tove Lo]Sweet Children 4/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt]Average Rating — 4.83/10Album Rating — ★★☆☆☆The Joker 7/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt/Anthony Rossomando] Wave 5/10 [Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt]
Average Song Ratings 10/10 — 9/10 — 8/10 — 7/10 — 6/10 — 5/10 — 4/10 — 3/10 — 2/10 — 1/10 — Average — Songwriter Average Ratings
Liam Gallagher Liam Gallagher/Andrew Wyatt Liam Gallagher/Simon Aldred Liam Gallagher/Greg Kurstin/Andrew Wyatt Liam Gallagher/Damon McMahon/Andrew Wyatt Andrew Wyatt/Michael Tighe
|
|