|
Post by glider on Sept 11, 2017 18:26:28 GMT -5
DM. 9.7/10 WTSMG. 9.0/10 BHN 8.5/10 TM. 9.5/10 SOTSOG. 8.0/10 HC 2.0/10 DBTT 4.5/10 DOYS 7.7/10 DGSS -3.1/10 NGHFB 6.5/10 BE 7.0/10 CY 7.3/10 This time, gauged by the quality of songs individually rather than the album overall.
|
|
|
Post by yerblues0 on Sept 14, 2017 8:45:43 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - 9 - Punk Oasis (What's The Story)Morning Glory? - 10 - Classic Oasis Be Here Now - 7 - Indulgent Oasis Standing The Shoulder Of Giants - 6 - Depressed Oasis Heathen Chemistry - 4 - I'd rather be in a 9 to 5 than Oasis Don't Believe The Truth - 7 - Steady Oasis Dig Out Your Soul - 6 - One eye on solo stardom Oasis Different Gear Still Speeding - 4 - Wish I was still in Oasis High Flying Birds - 3 - These gigs are not like with Oasis BE 6 - Temazepam Oasis Chasing Yesterday - 5 - Sara, can I rejoin Oasis As You Were - 8 - Who the fuck needs Oasis Are you tripping? AYW is better than the most Oasis albums and Chasing Yesterday? Gosh, Liam's fanboys are strange. Listen to your FWIW and Adele songwriters, kiddo, Liam's fanboys are so easy to please - all they need is derivative 'rock-n'roll'. Sometimes his fans are as cringeworthy as OD fangirls. PS (Not a Liam hater btw, always loved the Gallagher brothers equally). I wish Liam the best, sitting home is bad for him, I'm glad he's doing something, just not my cup of tea and his new alsum isn't a masterpiece.
|
|
|
Post by walterglass on Sept 14, 2017 8:49:04 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - 9 - Punk Oasis (What's The Story)Morning Glory? - 10 - Classic Oasis Be Here Now - 7 - Indulgent Oasis Standing The Shoulder Of Giants - 6 - Depressed Oasis Heathen Chemistry - 4 - I'd rather be in a 9 to 5 than Oasis Don't Believe The Truth - 7 - Steady Oasis Dig Out Your Soul - 6 - One eye on solo stardom Oasis Different Gear Still Speeding - 4 - Wish I was still in Oasis High Flying Birds - 3 - These gigs are not like with Oasis BE 6 - Temazepam Oasis Chasing Yesterday - 5 - Sara, can I rejoin Oasis As You Were - 8 - Who the fuck needs Oasis Are you tripping? AYW is better than the most Oasis albums and Chasing Yesterday? Gosh, Liam's fanboys are strange. Listen to your FWIW and Adele songwriters, kiddo, Liam's fanboys are so easy to please - all they need is derivative 'rock-n'roll'. Careful, you'll hurt my feelings. I'm a sensitive soul.
|
|
|
Post by bardes on Sept 14, 2017 8:49:09 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - 8 (What's The Story)Morning Glory? - 8 Be Here Now - 7 Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants - 6 Heathen Chemistry - 4 Don't Believe The Truth - 6 Dig Out Your Soul - 6,5
Different Gear Still Speeding - 3 High Flying Birds - 7 BE - 6 Chasing Yesterday - 5
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 14, 2017 9:04:53 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - 10 (What's The Story) Morning Glory? - 9.5 Be Here Now - 9.5 Standing On the Shoulder Of Giants - 7 Heathen Chemistry - 4 Don't Believe The Truth - 6 Dig Out Your Soul - 7
Different Gear Still Speeding - 3.5 High Flying Birds - 5 Beady Eye - 5.5 Chasing Yesterday - 6
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 14, 2017 9:12:32 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - 9 (What's The Story)Morning Glory? - 10 Be Here Now - 7.5 Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants - 8
Heathen Chemistry - 6 Don't Believe The Truth - 6 Dig Out Your Soul - 4
Different Gear Still Speeding - 4 High Flying Birds - 5 BE - 6
Chasing Yesterday - 8
|
|
|
Post by supernovadragon on Oct 6, 2017 8:04:07 GMT -5
Review of my ratings and including As You Were:
Definitely Maybe - 7 (What's The Story)Morning Glory - 9 Be Here Now - 9 The Masterplan - 7 Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants - 8 Heathen Chemistry - 6 Don't Believe The Truth - 5 Dig Out Your Soul - 4
Different Gear Still Speeding - 6 High Flying Birds #1 - 5 BE - 7 Chasing Yesterday - 6 As You Were - 9
|
|
|
Post by mrsifters80 on Oct 6, 2017 8:27:46 GMT -5
DM- 9.5 WTSMG- 9 BHN- 7.5 SOTSOG- 7.5 HC- 6 DBBT- 7 DOYS- 7
NGHFB- 7 DGSS- 6 BE- 6.5 CY- 7.5 ASW- 7.5
|
|
|
Post by andybellwillring on Oct 6, 2017 8:54:12 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - 8 (What's The Story)Morning Glory? - 9 Be Here Now - 8 Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants - 6 Heathen Chemistry - 3 Don't Believe The Truth - 5 Dig Out Your Soul - 7
Different Gear Still Speeding - Never listened to the whole album BE - 4
High Flying Birds - 7 Chasing Yesterday - 7
|
|
|
Post by balloonless on Oct 6, 2017 9:14:36 GMT -5
I think I look at this differently to most, I'd much rather listen to new Gallagher material to almost anything else post '97, so I compare albums to whats about at the time, as well as what I like.
Definitely Maybe 10/10 (What's The Story) Morning Glory? 10/10 Be Here Now 10/10 Standing On The Shoulder of Giants 8/10 Heathen Chemistry 6/10 Don't Believe The Truth 7/10 Dig Out Your Soul 7/10 Different Gear, Still Speeding 5/10 Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds 8/10 BE 7.5/10 Chasing Yesterday 8/10
|
|
|
Post by standbymoi on Oct 6, 2017 9:31:10 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by funhouse on Oct 6, 2017 11:31:58 GMT -5
9 10 9.25 7.5 6 7.5 7
4 7 6 7.5 | Definitely Maybe (What's The Story)Morning Glory? Be Here Now Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants Heathen Chemistry Don't Believe The Truth Dig Out Your Soul
Different Gear Still Speeding High Flying Birds BE Chasing Yesterday | [Godlike] [Godlike] [Godlike] [Fantastic] [Alright] [Fantastic] [Fantastic]
[Meh] [Fantastic] [Alright] [Fantastic] |
I find it hard to understand how the score 7/10 could be translated as "fantastic"
|
|
|
Post by funhouse on Oct 6, 2017 11:44:12 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe 9.5 WTSMG - 9.5 Be Here Now - 7.5/light 8 SOTSOG - 5.5 Heathen Chemistry - 5.5 Don't Believe The Truth - 4.5 Dig Out Your Soul - 6.5
To give the post-Oasis stuff a fair assessment, I'd have to listen to it again. But BE is the worst of them.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 6, 2017 11:46:01 GMT -5
I find it hard to understand how the score 7/10 could be translated as "fantastic" Godlike: 10.00-9.00 Fantastic: 8.99-7.00 Alright: 6.99-5.00 Meh: 4.99-3.00 Shite: 2.99-0.00 I suppose I could readjust this, but I'm not really in the mood at the moment.
|
|
|
Post by The Escapist on Oct 6, 2017 11:51:58 GMT -5
Rating the entire era and not just the original tracklistings:
Definitely Maybe (10) Morning Glory (10) Be Here Now (9) Standing on the Shoulders of Giants (7.5) Heathen Chemistry (4) Don't Believe the Truth (5) Dig Out Your Soul (6)
NGHFB (7) Chasing Yesterday (7.5)
Different Gear, Still Speeding (3) BE (5)
As You Were (6.5)
Notice Noel's upward trajectory since Heathen Chemistry. Hope that continues.
|
|
|
Post by matt on Oct 6, 2017 15:17:18 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - 10 Morning Glory - 10 Be Here Now - 7.5 The Masterplan - 10 Standing on the Shoulders of Giants - 6.5 Heathen Chemistry - 4 Don't Believe The Truth - 6 Dig Out Your Soul - 6
Different Gear Still Speeding - 3 BE - 5
High Flying Birds - 7 Chasing Yesterday - 7
As You Were - 7
-----
Common trend with the brothers solo albums - no Gem and Andy, therefore these albums emphasise the pure essence of the brothers characters more readily than maybe a lot of post-90s Oasis albums and obviously Beady Eye. For sure, while half of Liam's album is written by professional songwriters, the album shows why they are professionals. They've understood Liam's character more readily than his ex-Beady Eye bandmates and provided him with the arsenal of tunes that brings the best out of his voice. No songs from a bloke from a Gary Glitter inspired tribute band Heavy Fucking Stereo, no shallow husk of a guy who was unbelievably the driving force from Ride.
Nice guys but god their creative input was dire, so while it's great to see both brothers throwing off such excess baggage, it's also great to see them swallowing their pride a bit and bringing in the creative expertise of top professionals, whether it be songwriters with Liam or a renowned producer with Noel.
|
|
|
Post by matt on Oct 6, 2017 15:20:47 GMT -5
Rating the entire era and not just the original tracklistings: Definitely Maybe (10) Morning Glory (10) Be Here Now (9) Standing on the Shoulders of Giants (7.5) Heathen Chemistry (4) Don't Believe the Truth (5) Dig Out Your Soul (6) NGHFB (7) Chasing Yesterday (7.5) Different Gear, Still Speeding (3) BE (5) As You Were (6.5) Notice Noel's upward trajectory since Heathen Chemistry. Hope that continues. With a few points out here and there, very similar to mine.
|
|
|
Post by The Escapist on Oct 6, 2017 17:28:58 GMT -5
Rating the entire era and not just the original tracklistings: Definitely Maybe (10) Morning Glory (10) Be Here Now (9) Standing on the Shoulders of Giants (7.5) Heathen Chemistry (4) Don't Believe the Truth (5) Dig Out Your Soul (6) NGHFB (7) Chasing Yesterday (7.5) Different Gear, Still Speeding (3) BE (5) As You Were (6.5) Notice Noel's upward trajectory since Heathen Chemistry. Hope that continues. With a few points out here and there, very similar to mine. Great minds rate alike
|
|
|
Post by Beady’s Here Now on Oct 6, 2017 22:21:45 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe: 10/10
What's the Story: 10/10
The Masterplan: 10/10
Be Here Now: 9/10
Standing On The Shoulder of Giants: 7/10
Heathen Chemistry: 4/10....Utter fucking shite
Don't Believe The Truth: 7.5/10
Dig Out Your Soul: 8/10
---------
Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds: 8/10
Chasing Yesterday: 7.5/10
---------
Different Gear, Still Speeding: 6/10
BE: 5.5/10....Too much nonsense going on with it
---------
As You Were: 8/10
YEAH, I KNOW WHAT I KNOW
|
|
|
Post by Spaceman on Oct 7, 2017 9:42:57 GMT -5
"That turned us into proper, like, global, worldwide fucking idiots or whatever.” lmao
|
|
|
Post by thatlad on Oct 7, 2017 9:45:06 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe => 9.5/10 (What's The Story?) Morning Glory => 10/10 Be Here Now => 7/10 ...DYKWIM, SBM, DGA, BHN and SY saves it, for me. The Masterplan => 9/10 SOTSOG => 5.5/10 Heathen Chemistry => 5/10 Don't Believe The Truth => 5/10 Dig Out Your Soul => 6.5/10
Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds => invalid Chasing Yesterday => 5/10
Different Gear, Still Speeding => 3/10 BE - 3/10
As You Were - 7.5
|
|
|
Post by nutsngum on Oct 7, 2017 12:22:17 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - 9.5 (WTS) MG - 9.5 Be Here Now - 6 Standing on the Shoulder of Giants - 6 Heathen Chemistry - 3 DBTT - 5 Dig Out Your Soul - 6
NGHFB - 7.5 Chasing Yesterday - 7
DGSS - 3 BE - 4
As You Were - 7
|
|
|
Post by Paul_Stone342 on Oct 16, 2017 22:53:13 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - 9/10 (What's The Story) Morning Glory? - 10/10 Be Here Now - 8.5/10 Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants - 7/10 Heathen Chemistry - 6.5/10 Don't Believe The Truth - 5/10 Dig Out Your Soul - 6/10
-------------------------------
NG'S High Flying Birds - 7/10 ("Stop The Clocks" is the original) Chasing Yesterday - 6.5/10
-------------------------------
Different Gear, Still Spedding - 6/10 BE - 4/10
-------------------------------
As You Were - 7.5/10
|
|
|
Post by seanrulesrh on Oct 16, 2017 23:44:49 GMT -5
Definitely Maybe - 8'5 (WTS) Morning Glory? - 9 Be Here Now - 6 The Masterplan - 8 SOTSOG - 8'7 Heathen Chemistry - 6 Don't Believe The Truth - 7'3 Dig Out Your Soul - 8'9 Different Gear,Still Speeding - 6 NGHFB - 7'5 BE - 7'5 Chasing Yesterday - 8 As You Were - 8'2
|
|
|
Post by Beady’s Here Now on Oct 17, 2017 14:59:08 GMT -5
On the eve of both Liam and Noel's solo albums coming out. Let's revisit and rate each album out of 10. Definitely Maybe - 6 This forum isn't Pitchfork, mate.
|
|